header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
January 21
1914 - Signal newspaper owner-editor Scott Newhall born in San Francisco [story]
Scott Newhall


(CN) — A defense contractor responsible for cleaning up pollution at a facility where most munitions manufacturing was done under contracts with the U.S. military can seek cost recovery from the government, the Ninth Circuit ruled Monday.

Whittaker Corporation manufactured and tested munitions for the government at a facility in Santa Clarita, Calif., for 20 years, according to court records. The site was previously owned by the Bermite Powder Company.

Between 1954, when Bermite was in charge, until 1987, when Whittaker ceased operations at the site, about 90 percent of the munitions manufacturing and testing at the site was done under contracts with the U.S. military.

In 2000, the Castaic Lake Water Agency and other providers who pumped water out of ground wells near the Bermite site filed a lawsuit against Whittaker under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act, or CERCLA. They claimed that Whittaker’s operations had contaminated their water supplies with a pollutant called perchlorate and other hazardous chemicals.

Residents Invited To Discuss Whittaker Bermite Property CleanupWhittaker and its insurers settled the case in 2007, agreeing to reimburse the water providers for costs they incurred removing the perchlorate pollution from their wells. Whittaker also agreed to purchase replacement water.

Although Whittaker was found liable for a specific set of the providers’ costs of responding to the defense contractor’s pollution, Whittaker was not ordered to clean up the Bermite site.

In 2013, Whittaker filed its own lawsuit under CERCLA, seeking recovery from the United States for expenses Whittaker incurred since the 1980s investigating and cleaning the Bermite site. Whittaker sought reimbursement of costs for soil sampling, excavations, surveys and remedial operations addressing solvents and heavy metals.

U.S. District Judge Fernando Olguin ruled that Castaic Lake’s lawsuit against Whittaker precluded the defense contractor from bringing a CERCLA cost recovery against the United States. The judge said that Whittaker only had the right to seek reimbursement for paying more than its fair share in the Castaic Lake suit.

A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit reversed Olguin’s decision on Monday, finding that the expenses Whittaker seeks to recover from the government are separate from the expenses for which the defense contractor was found liable in the Castaic Lake case.

Women assemble fuses at Bermite Powder Co., circa 1955.

Women assemble fuses at Bermite Powder Co., circa 1955.

“Whittaker’s liability in a prior case did not limit it to seeking contribution for all of its expenses, so Whittaker may use a CERCLA cost recovery action to seek reimbursement for the cleanup costs at issue in this case,” Judge Mary Murguia wrote on behalf of the panel.

Although Whittaker’s right to bring a contribution claim was triggered by the Castaic Lake lawsuit, that did not require Whittaker to also bring a contribution action for costs for which it was not found liable in that lawsuit, the Ninth Circuit ruled.

“If the right to contribution were so broad, there would be no reason for courts to evaluate different sets of expenses separately in deciding whether a party has a contribution claim, yet evaluating expenses separately is precisely what courts have done,” Murguia said.

Congress did not intend for parties who have been sued in cost recovery actions to be forced to bring all of their own CERCLA claims in the form of a contribution action on an accelerated timeframe, Murguia wrote for the majority.

Today, the Bermite site is sometimes used for filming.

Old-time SCV residents remember things going “boom” at Bermite. Today, it’s just movie special effects.

Judge John Owens dissented in part, finding that case law has drifted from what Congress intended when it passed and amended CERCLA in the 1980s.

“Requiring all related contribution claims to be ‘dealt with in a single action’ would ‘encourage private party settlements and cleanup’ because the threat of being sued ‘as a third-party defendant, concurrent with the original litigation, has the effect of bringing all such responsible parties to the bargaining table at an early date,'” Owens wrote.

The judge added that the panel’s holding “permits adversaries to fight for generations over moldy leftover crumbs,” which is “(g)ood for lawyers, but bad for the environment and communities affected by the contamination.”

Whittaker’s attorney Kevin Fong and the U.S. Justice Department declined to comment on the ruling.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

No Comments

    Leave a Comment


    SCV NewsBreak
    Current Time 0:00
    /
    Duration Time 0:00
    Loaded: 0%
    Progress: 0%
    Stream TypeLIVE
    Remaining Time -0:00
     
    1x
    LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
    Monday, Jan 20, 2025
    L.A. Public Health Windblown Dust, Ash Advisory
    The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is issuing a windblown dust and ash advisory following strong Santa Ana winds expected to affect the region through Tuesday, Jan. 21 at 10 p.m.
    Monday, Jan 20, 2025
    County Warns: Dangerous Santa Ana Winds, Extreme Fire Weather
    Ahead of another forecasted Particularly Dangerous Situation Red Flag warning and extreme fire weather, Los Angeles County is asking the public to prepare.
    Friday, Jan 17, 2025
    Keep Up With Our Facebook

    Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
    1914 - Signal newspaper owner-editor Scott Newhall born in San Francisco [story]
    Scott Newhall
    District Attorney Nathan J. Hochman has announced the appointment of Michael Gennaco as Special Prosecutor who is among the nation’s foremost experts in civil rights and police misconduct cases.
    DA Hires Special Prosecutor for Police Misconduct Cases
    In response to the ongoing challenges posed by the Palisades and Eaton Fires, the county of Los Angeles Department of Animal Care and Control has mobilized its resources and partnerships to ensure the safety and well-being of the animals affected.
    DACC Facilitates Adoption, Rescue Efforts in Response to Wildfires
    The WiSH Education Foundation Wednesday Webinar series continues 5-6:30 p.m. Wednesday, Feb. 12 with "College Admissions for Visual and Performing Arts Majors."
    Feb. 12: WiSH Webinar on ‘College Admissions for Visual, Performing Arts Majors’
    The regular meeting of the Saugus Union School District Governing Board will take place Tuesday, Jan. 21 beginning at 6:30 p.m.
    Jan. 21: SUSD Governing Board Regular Meeting
    A Better World Running will host the Cupid Dash 5k, 10k, 15k, Half Marathon 7:30 a.m. Sunday, Feb. 16 at West Creek Park 24247 Village Circle Drive, Valencia, CA 91354.
    Feb. 16: Cupid Dash 5k, 10k, 15k, Half Marathon
    The Los Angeles County Department of Military & Veterans Affairs will resume normal operations at Bob Hope Patriotic Hall (1816 S. Figueroa St., Los Angeles, California, 90015) on Tuesday, Jan. 21.
    Jan. 21: Normal Operations Resume at Bob Hope Patriotic Hall
    The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is issuing a windblown dust and ash advisory following strong Santa Ana winds expected to affect the region through Tuesday, Jan. 21 at 10 p.m.
    L.A. Public Health Windblown Dust, Ash Advisory
    The Master's University men's basketball defense stepped up in the final moments of the game to get an 80-72 conference road win over Benedictine Mesa Thursday night, Jan. 16.
    Defense Stepped Up in Mustangs Win over BenU
    Three different players each scored 17 points and the team shot nearly 50 percent from the field as The Master's University women's basketball team defeated Benedictine Mesa 83-71 Thursday night, Jan. 16 in Mesa, Ariz.
    TMU Women’s Hoops Gets Road Win over Redhawks
    College of the Canyons men's basketball had four players reach double-digits but it wasn't enough to keep pace with No. 5 state-ranked Citrus College in a 111-77 road affair Wednesday night, Jan. 15.
    Canyons Can’t Get Past No. 5 Citrus College
    College of the Canyons women's basketball is still looking for its first conference victory after its 75-54 road loss at Citrus College on Wednesday, Jan. 15.
    Ceja, Saridin Shine, Cougars Fall at Citrus
    Ahead of another forecasted Particularly Dangerous Situation Red Flag warning and extreme fire weather, Los Angeles County is asking the public to prepare.
    County Warns: Dangerous Santa Ana Winds, Extreme Fire Weather
    1993 - Hart High grad Dee Dee Myers (1979) becomes first female White House press secretary [story]
    Dee Dee Myers
    1967 - Original airing of Star Trek "Arena" Episode: Kirk battles the Gorn commander (Saugus resident Bobby Clark) at Vasquez Rocks [watch]
    Kirk vs. Gorn commander
    1899 - Martin & Richard Wood buy J.H. Tolfree's Saugus Eating House (still inside Saugus Depot), rename it Saugus Cafe [story]
    Saugus Cafe
    Fritz Coleman’s show "Unassisted Living," in Residency at the El Oortal Monroe Forum in North Hollywood, will be performed on Sunday, Jan. 26 t0 benefit the California Community Foundation Wildlife Recovery Fund with 100% of all profits raised donated to the fund.
    Jan. 26: Fritz Coleman’s ‘Unassisted Living’ to Benefit Wildfire Recovery Fund
    The Santa Clarita Community College District Board of Trustees will hold a business meeting Wednesday, Jan. 22, beginning at 5 p.m. The board will first meet in closed session at 3 p.m.
    Jan. 22: COC Board Business Meeting
    The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Homicide Bureau continues its dedicated efforts to locate individuals reported missing following the devastating Eaton and Palisades fires.
    LASD Reports 17 Still Missing in L.A. Area Wildfires
    The Canyon Theatre Guild opens the Broadway musical, "West Side Story" on Saturday, Jan. 18 on stage at the community theater in Old Town Newhall.
    ‘West Side Story’ Opens at the Canyon Theatre Guild
    The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board has unanimously approved the appointment of Jordan Meraz as the new Director of Technology Services.
    Jordan Meraz Named Hart Director of Technology Services
    The American Red Cross is offering financial assistance for families whose homes were damaged or destroyed by Los Angeles County wildfires. Assistance available to those affected by Eaton, Palisades, Hurst and Kenneth fires.
    Red Cross Offers Financial Assistance to Fire Victims
    Cal Fire and the Los Angeles County Fire Department have reported that containment efforts continue for all three activie fires still burning in Southern California.
    Repopulation Efforts in Eaton, Palisades Fire Areas, 27 Fire Deaths Reported
    SCVNews.com