header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
June 24
1980 - Saugus Train Station relocated to Hart Park, Newhall [story]
Saugus Train Station


| Friday, Sep 7, 2018
California Gov. Jerry Brown signs Senate Bill 10, which replaced the state’s money bail system with risk assessments in a bid to incarcerate fewer people ahead of trial or sentencing. (Ryan Grant/California Department of Tax and Fee Administration)
California Gov. Jerry Brown signs Senate Bill 10, which replaced the state’s money bail system with risk assessments in a bid to incarcerate fewer people ahead of trial or sentencing. | Photo: Ryan Grant/California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.

 

By Maria Dinzeo

OAKLAND – Despite the recent passage of a law banning the money bail system in California, a federal judge will still have to decide whether bail is constitutional in a legal challenge of the practice.

A trial in a class action brought by low-income arrestees mounting a constitutional challenge to bail was set to start on Sept. 17, but at a Friday pretrial hearing, U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers asked attorneys for both sides to submit renewed motions for summary judgment.

Gonzalez Rogers opened the hearing by declaring the case all but moot in light of Senate Bill 10, which Gov. Jerry Brown signed into law last week.

The bill replaces California’s current money bail system with pretrial risk assessments and lets local courts decide who should be released while awaiting trial or sentencing – a framework that is supposed to be fairer for those who cannot afford to pay their way out of jail.

“My own view is that if the case isn’t moot, it’s pretty darn close to moot,” Gonzalez Rogers said.

By its conclusion, however, the lawyers had convinced her to take another look since the current bail schedules will be in effect for at least another year. The California Bail Reform Act doesn’t take effect until Oct. 1, 2019, and a referendum is already under way to repeal it.

“We agree that If SB 10 had been implemented as of the day of passage that the case would have been moot. Our concern is we have a certified class of pre-arraignment arrestees who are still subject to a bail schedule in San Francisco,” class attorney Sadik Huseny told Gonzalez Rogers. “In the next year, if the bail schedule is being used by the sheriff against our class, we do have a little bit of a live controversy for a year.”

Representing the California Bail Agents Association, attorney Harmeet Dhillon said she doesn’t believe the case is moot at all.

“There has been a class certified and that class has asserted deprivation of liberty. It is up to two years or more in San Francisco where these rights will be affected,” Dhillon said. She also noted that if the referendum gathers enough signatures to be put to a vote in November 2020, the new law’s effective date could be pushed back even further.

“If the referendum qualifies, SB 10 will not become law until December 2020 if it fails, or never, if it succeeds,” she said.

She added if Gonzalez Rogers rules the case moot, someone else could bring a new case in the interim, effectively wasting court resources on another lawsuit.

Gonzalez Rogers had her own problem with the case, noting the California Bail Agents Association may not even be an appropriate intervenor since it is defending the current bail system on behalf of the state of California even though all three branches of government oppose it.

“The government’s position is they are putting in a new system because they are not supportive of the law as it stands,” the judge said. “But they can’t do it today because they need time to create the structure for changing it. The legislative, executive and the judicial branches, the entire state government, has a position which is diametrically opposed to what the CBAA is advocating for and the only reason to allow you to intervene was to defend the law in the shoes of the government. I just don’t understand how I can permit you to continue to defend something in the shoes of someone who says we’re repealing this. It doesn’t make logical sense to me.”

Dhillon replied: “The current law is still in effect, and will possibly be in effect for two years and will possibly be in effect forever.”

Further complicating matters is the question of what relief the class could receive should Gonzalez Rogers find the bail system unconstitutional. Huseny said he worried that even if the judge rules in favor of the plaintiffs, the sheriff could put another framework in place that yields the same unfair results, like requiring a fee for pretrial diversion.

Huseny said his side had been trying to work with attorneys for San Francisco County Sheriff Vicki Hennessy, but their efforts had not been reciprocated. Jeremy Goldman with the San Francisco City Attorney’s Office said they had already filed a plan with the court.

“We don’t know what the plaintiffs want,” he said.

The judge advised the parties not to get ahead of themselves.

“What I think would be best is not to get into relief issues. Let’s take this a step at a time,” Gonzalez Rogers said. “And you can’t have relief until I rule it as unconstitutional.”

Gonzalez Rogers ordered Huseny to submit a renewed motion for summary judgment by Sept. 28. She gave Dillon until Oct. 19 to respond. The parties are due in court Dec. 12 for further argument.

In an interview outside the courtroom, Dhillon said she thought Gonzalez Rogers had done the right thing. “We think it was a prudent way to handle it. No one wants to waste the court’s time.”

Dhillon added the potential legal challenges to the SB 10 could delay its implementation indefinitely. It will probably take an amendment to the California Constitution for a change in the bail system to actually stick.

“There’s a lot going on here,” she said. “The fact that the Legislature passes a law does not make it constitutional. SB 10 is never going to become law, that’s my prediction.”

Despite Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye’s outspoken opposition to bail, even the California Supreme Court hasn’t ruled the issue settled with SB 10’s passage.

Earlier this year, court granted review in the case of Kenneth Humphrey, a San Francisco man whose $350,000 bail led to an appellate court order that judges consider a person’s ability to pay when setting bail.

In May, the state high court said it will consider whether the appellate court erred in determining that due process and equal protection require judges to consider a defendant’s ability to pay when setting bail, whether a judge must consider public and victim safety and under what circumstances a judge may deny bail in noncapital cases.

“The California Supreme Court still views there to be a live issue here,” Dhillon said.

Though the California Bail Reform Act was touted in the Legislature as the path to doing away with a system that penalizes the poor, many civil rights and victim advocacy groups have criticized it for various reasons.

Some claim a new system that relies on pretrial risk assessments will disproportionally keep people of color in jail based on biased algorithms. Others say victims’ needs are not being considered. Some have also argued bail is a civil right in itself.

Dhillon said the referendum to repeal SB 10 is “95 percent likely” to qualify for the November 2020 ballot.

“The Legislature might be pleased with itself, but the civil rights community has condemned this law,” Dhillon said.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

3 Comments

  1. You go California ????

  2. Dave Rickmers says:

    Lawyers are a trip.

  3. Leonid Kamenetsky says:

    SB 10 is Unconditional on State level and in the federal level .

    Therefore this bill is 100% fraud!!!!!

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, Jun 21, 2024
Supes Urge Newsom Not to Cut L.A. County Inmate Firefighting Crews
Los Angeles County Supervisor Kathryn Barger and Board of Supervisors Chair Lindsey Horvath have sent an open letter to Governor Gavin Newsom urging him to continue funding the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations hand crews who currently help the Los Angeles County Fire Department tackle wildland fires.
Friday, Jun 21, 2024
Santa Clarita Now Accepting Project Proposals for Make A Difference Day
The city of Santa Clarita invites local schools and nonprofits to submit a proposal outlining a project that can benefit from volunteer support as part of Make A Difference Day on Saturday, Oct. 26.
Friday, Jun 21, 2024
June 25: City Council Meets on Open Space, Budget, Town Center Specific Plan
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold a regular meeting on Tuesday, June 25 at 6 p.m. that includes a host of issues including assessments, taxes, fees and budgets in addition to continued hearings on the Town Center Specific Plan.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1980 - Saugus Train Station relocated to Hart Park, Newhall [story]
Saugus Train Station
1946, 11:20pm: William S. Hart, 81, dies at L.A.'s California Lutheran Hospital, leaving his Newhall estate and his (now West) Hollywood home to the public [story]
Hart dies
1972 - Vasquez Rocks added to National Register of Historic Places [list]
Vasquez Rocks
Los Angeles County Supervisor Kathryn Barger and Board of Supervisors Chair Lindsey Horvath have sent an open letter to Governor Gavin Newsom urging him to continue funding the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations hand crews who currently help the Los Angeles County Fire Department tackle wildland fires.
Supes Urge Newsom Not to Cut L.A. County Inmate Firefighting Crews
Give the gift of life, an upcoming blood drive is scheduled for Friday, June 28, from 10 a.m. – 4 p.m., at The Centre, 20880 Centre Pointe Parkway, Santa Clarita, CA 91350. The blood drive will be held in Cedar Hall.
June 28: City Hosts Blood Drive at The Centre
The city of Santa Clarita invites local schools and nonprofits to submit a proposal outlining a project that can benefit from volunteer support as part of Make A Difference Day on Saturday, Oct. 26.
Santa Clarita Now Accepting Project Proposals for Make A Difference Day
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold a regular meeting on Tuesday, June 25 at 6 p.m. that includes a host of issues including assessments, taxes, fees and budgets in addition to continued hearings on the Town Center Specific Plan.
June 25: City Council Meets on Open Space, Budget, Town Center Specific Plan
Part of the Summer Theatre Festival by Santa Clarita Shakespeare, "An Evening of Absurdity" will run July 12-21 at the MAIN, 24266 Main Street., Newhall, CA 91321.
The MAIN Presents ‘An Evening of Absurdity’
The city of Santa Clarita has issued a traffic advisory for daytime lane closures at Copper Hill and Rio Norte Drive beginning Monday, June 24.
June 24: Traffic Advisory Lane Closures Copper Hill/Rio Norte Drive
Santa Clarita will celebrate this year's Fourth of July with the Santa Clarita Valley Rotary Club's pancake breakfast, Santa Clarita Valley Parade Committee's Fourth of July Parade and city of Santa Clarita fireworks show.
Fourth of July Events in Santa Clarita
The California Department of Public Health is warning consumers not to eat, sell or serve any flavor of Diamond Shruumz brand chocolate bars, cones and gummies, which contain a proprietary mushroom blend. These products, known as microdose products, have led to multiple illnesses and hospitalizations in 16 states, including at least one poisoning in California.
California Public Health Warns Consumers About Diamond Shruumz Products
The Cube – Ice and Entertainment Center, Powered by FivePoint Valencia, will hold the inaugural Girls and Women’s Three-on-Three Hockey Tournament on Saturday, June 22.
June 22: The Cube Hosts Inaugural Girls, Women’s Hockey Tourney
Join Santa Clarita's oldest and largest running event, the 40th annual Independence Day Classic, Thursday July 4, from 7 a.m.- 10 a.m. at Newhall Memorial Park, 24933 Newhall Ave., Newhall, CA 91321.
July 4: Independence Day Classic
A special meeting of the William S. Hart Union High School District’s Governing Board will be held Wednesday, June 26, beginning at 8 a.m.
June 26: Hart District Governing Board Special Meeting
The California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) reports that the fast moving Post Fire that broke out in Gorman on Saturday, June 15 around 1:47 p.m. has reached 15,690 acres and is now 61% contained. This latest CAL FIRE update was issued at 7:44 a.m. on Friday, June 21.
Post Fire 61 Percent Contained, Pyramid Lake Remains Closed
For die-hard "The Love Boat" fans, the ultimate cruise experience just dropped anchor. Princess Cruises, which is headquartered in Santa Clarita, has announced an exclusive VIP package for its Love Boat themed cruise Aug. 32-Sept. 7 that promises intimate, up-close interactions with the show's beloved characters: Doc, Gopher, Isaac and Vicki Stubing.
Princess Cruises Offers ‘The Love Boat’ Celebration Cruise
The Valley Industry Association will host VIA Cocktails & Conversation: An Evening with CA State Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo on Wednesday, July 10.
July 10: Cocktails & Conversation with Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo
1941 - Ernie Hickson buys out Trem Carr's interest in their Monogram movie ranch, renames it "Placeritos" (later called Melody) [story]
Ernie Hickson
The California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) reports that the fast moving Post Fire that broke out in Gorman on Saturday, June 15 around 1:47 p.m. has reached 15,690 acres and is now 24% contained. This latest CAL FIRE update was issued at 7 a.m. on Thursday.
Post Fire 47 Percent Contained, Reported 15,690 Acres
The Santa Clarita Arts Commission will hold a study session Thursday, June 27, at 6 p.m., in the Carl Boyer Room at City Hall.
June 27: Arts Commission Study Session
Katherine Dyer has signed her national letter of intent to continue her swimming career at The Master's University.
Katherine Dyer Commits to TMU Swim Program
Every summer, Santa Clarita’s very own Central Park, located at 27150 Bouquet Canyon Road, transforms into a premiere venue for live musical performances where friends, families and neighbors come together to sing and dance the night away.
Jason Gibbs | Get Ready for Concerts in the Park Summer Soundtrack
California State University, Northridge's Trey Knight, Chase Mars and David Phillips, Jr. will compete at the 2024 United States Olympic Trials in Eugene, Ore. beginning June 27.
Several Matadors Qualify for 2024 U.S. Olympic Trials
SCVNews.com