header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
March 4
1940 - NYC premiere of "The Marines Fly High" starring Lucille Ball, filmed in Placerita Canyon [story] Marines Fly High


By Nicholas Iovino

SAN FRANCISCO – The Trump administration’s push to add a citizenship question to the 2020 Census suffered a major setback Wednesday when a federal judge issued a second nationwide injunction against the policy, finding it would “threaten the very foundation of our democracy.”

U.S. District Judge Richard Seeborg is the second federal judge in less than two months to find U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross used a bogus reason to justify adding a question that evidence suggests will suppress immigrant and Latino participation in the decennial survey.

California and six cities, including Los Angeles and San Jose, sued the Commerce secretary after he decided to add the question to the census in March last year. The state and cities say an undercount could lead to a reduction in federal funds and congressional representation.

A May 2017 email from Ross stating he was “mystified” nothing had been done to advance his “months-old request” to add a citizenship question was the primary piece of evidence for pretext cited in Seeborg’s ruling.

After that email was sent, Ross’s subordinates embarked on “a cynical search to find some reason, any reason, or an agency request to justify that preordained result,” Seeborg wrote in his 126-page decision.

In December 2017, the Justice Department sent a letter stating that it needed citizenship data to help enforce the Voting Rights Act. That letter came only after the Department of Homeland Security and Justice Department, initially, refused to request the data.

According to evidence cited in the record, then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions intervened after a private phone conversation with Ross and ordered the Justice Department to pen the letter.

Sessions then forbade his subordinates from meeting with Census Bureau staff to discuss the request or alternatives for obtaining citizenship data, Seeborg wrote in his ruling.

“It is clear from the administrative record that Secretary Ross’s purported reliance on the DOJ letter was nothing more than a pretext designed to provide cover for Secretary Ross’s unexplained desire to add the citizenship question to the census,” Seeborg wrote.

The judge also found adding a citizenship question would actually defeat the stated purpose of obtaining accurate citizenship data because evidence shows the question would will deter immigrants and Latinos from participating, leading to an undercount of noncitizens.

Seeborg’s ruling also gave opponents of the citizenship question a broader victory than the one obtained in a parallel lawsuit in New York in January. While both judges found the decision to add the question was arbitrary and capricious, Seeborg further ruled the question violates the U.S. Constitution’s enumeration clause, which requires an accurate count of the U.S. population every 10 years.

Seeborg found evidence of the question’s impact on Latino and immigrant participation, compounded by the current political climate and debate over President Donald Trump’s hard-line immigration policies, would undermine the “strong constitutional interest” in obtaining an accurate count.

He cautioned that his ruling does not suggest that a citizenship question could never be added to the decennial survey, as it was in 1950 and census surveys prior to that.

But when evidence shows adding a question will hurt accuracy to the point of jeopardizing funding and congressional representation for states and localities, “the government must identify a legitimate governmental purpose that is sufficiently weighty to justify this significant harm to the census,” Seeborg concluded.

The judge also cited the Supreme Court’s 2013 decision striking down parts of the Voting Rights Act in Shelby County v. Holder as evidence that a government action’s constitutionality can change over time depending on social and political circumstances.

“The fact that the citizenship question may have been perfectly harmless in 1950, or that may be harmless again in the year 2050 is of little consequence to the Secretary’s constitutional obligations with respect to the accuracy of the 2020 census,” Seeborg wrote.

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra praised the ruling as a victory that will safeguard fair representation and federal funding for California and its communities.

“Justice has prevailed for each and every Californian who should raise their hands to be counted in the 2020 census without being discouraged by a citizenship question,” Becerra wrote in an emailed statement. “We look forward to a 2020 census free of partisanship, where every person can be counted equally and without prejudice.”

The Justice Department did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment Wednesday.

Because the 2020 census survey must be finalized this summer, the Supreme Court agreed last month to hear a challenge against U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman’s Jan. 15 ruling against the citizenship question. It was the first time in 15 years the high court chose to hear a case not yet reviewed by an intermediate appeals court.

The justices could decide to add Seeborg’s ruling to the scope of their review. The Supreme Court is expected to hear oral arguments on the case in late April and issue a decision before the end of June.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, Mar 1, 2024
6,550 New Homes Planned for Center of City
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold a study session Wednesday, March 6, at 5 p.m., to discuss the proposed Sunridge development by Urban West, which would be located at the site commonly known as the Whittaker-Bermite property.
Friday, Mar 1, 2024
CalArts Alum Wins Silver Bear Best Director at Berlin Film Festival
California Institute of the Arts alum and School of Film/Video special faculty Nelson Carlos De Los Santos Arias (Film/Video MFA 14) won the Silver Bear for Best Director at the 2024 Berlin Film Festival (Berlinale) on Feb. 24 for his feature film, "Pepe."
Friday, Mar 1, 2024
Applications Now Available for CA Credit Union’s Summer Internship
Applications are now available for California Credit Union’s Summer Internship Program for local high school seniors and college students.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1940 - NYC premiere of "The Marines Fly High" starring Lucille Ball, filmed in Placerita Canyon [story] Marines Fly High
1882 - George Campton's Newhall general store explodes [story]
general store
1938 - Great Flood of 1938 causes massive destruction and death across the greater Los Angeles region [story]
flooding
A strong fourth quarter turned a close game into The Master's University favor as the women's basketball team defeated the Hope International Royals 75-61 Thursday night in the first round of the GSAC Championship Tournament being played in Atherton, Calif.
Lady Mustangs Move on to GSAC Tourney Semis
The city of Santa Clarita is inviting artists to submit artwork to be considered for upcoming exhibitions.
City Seeking Artists, Artwork for Upcoming Exhibitions
MONTEREY PARK — No. 20 College of the Canyons suffered a 93-78 loss at No. 13 East L.A. College in the opening round of the 3C2A Southern California Regional Playoffs on Wednesday to see its season come to a close.
Season Ends for Lady Cougs Basketball
Eccentric relatives, love, mystery, family secrets and maybe even murder.
Mayor Cameron Smyth | “The Woman in the Castello”
VENTURA — College of the Canyons bounced back into the win column in a big way with a shortened 16-1 road victory at Ventura College on Tuesday, snapping a four-game losing streak in the process.
Lady Cougs Snap Four-Game Losing Streak
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold a study session Wednesday, March 6, at 5 p.m., to discuss the proposed Sunridge development by Urban West, which would be located at the site commonly known as the Whittaker-Bermite property.
6,550 New Homes Planned for Center of City
California Institute of the Arts alum and School of Film/Video special faculty Nelson Carlos De Los Santos Arias (Film/Video MFA 14) won the Silver Bear for Best Director at the 2024 Berlin Film Festival (Berlinale) on Feb. 24 for his feature film, "Pepe."
CalArts Alum Wins Silver Bear Best Director at Berlin Film Festival
Applications are now available for California Credit Union’s Summer Internship Program for local high school seniors and college students.
Applications Now Available for CA Credit Union’s Summer Internship
The William S. Hart Union High School District will host its annual Honor Band Concert Saturday, March 2, at 6:30 p.m., at the Hart High School Auditorium.
March 2: Annual Hart District Honor Band Concert
Light snow fell Thursday as state workers began the third snow survey of the season.
Upcoming Storm Could Boost California Snowpack Above Normal
1990 - President George H.W. Bush and Sheriff Sherman Block dedicate new North County Correctional Facility in Castaic [story]
ribbon cutting
The Master's University announced Kaleb Lowery was named co-Player of the Year in the conference and Ty Harper was named All-Golden State Athletic Conference in men's basketball for the 2023-24 season.
TMU’s Lowery Earns Co-Player of the Year; Harper Named All-GSAC
College of the Canyons student-athletes Aaliyah Garcia (women's basketball) and Jerome Hughes (men's track & field) have been named the COC Athletic Department's Women's & Men's Student-Athletes of the Week for the period running Feb. 19-24.
COC Names Aaliyah Garcia, Jerome Hughes Athletes of the Week
SCV Water invites the community to learn more about the Agency’s 5-year Strategic Plan through a special virtual presentation on Monday, March 25, from 6 p.m. to 7 p.m.
March 25: SCV Water Five-Year Strategic Plan Webinar
Rancho Pico and Rio Norte Junior High schools were named among the 293 middle and high schools that have been selected for the prestigious 2024 California Distinguished Schools Program, State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond announced Thursday.
Rancho Pico, Rio Norte Named Among California Distinguished Schools
Santa Clarita Symphony Orchestra is preparing for an outstanding year in 2024.
Santa Clarita Symphony Orchestra Announces New Venue, Performances
The Santa Clarita Sheriff’s Station Off-Highway Vehicle Team was created nearly 20 years ago to help address off-highway vehicle violations.
Public Encouraged to Comment, Review Off-Highway Vehicle Grant
As we travel onward into 2024, our City continues to remain resilient and steadfast in its commitment to meeting our residents’ needs and preserving our exceptional quality of life.
Marsha McLean | Santa Clarita’s Reliable Transit Alternatives
This week, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors unanimously passed a motion introduced by Supervisor Kathryn Barger, whose Fifth District includes the Santa Clarita Valley, and co-authored by Supervisor  Lindsey P. Horvath that mobilizes the County’s advocacy on behalf of homeowners who are struggling to get or keep their insurance coverage due to wildfire threat. 
Supes Seek Investigation of Home Insurance Providers’ Policies
SCV Water was recently awarded a $2 million grant under the Bureau of Reclamation’s FY 2023 WaterSMART Water and Energy Efficiency Grant Program.
SCV Water’s New $2M Grant to Support Conservation Programs
The California Department of Transportation has scheduled lane closures on the northbound and southbound State Route 14 between Technology Drive in Palmdale and Avenue A in Lancaster, closing up to three lanes.
Caltrans Announces Another Round of SR-14 Lane Closures
SCVNews.com