[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: The Superior Alternative | 02-20-2017
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
July 25
1915 - Pioneer Juan Batista Suraco buried in a family graveyard, currently unmarked, in Bouquet Canyon near Benz Road [story]

Commentary by Steve Lee
| Monday, Feb 20, 2017

The hearing on the final environmental impact report for the expansion of the Chiquita Canyon Landfill will be held Wednesday, March 1, at Rancho Pico High School, 26250 Valencia Blvd., from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m.

Many years have passed since the process started. The first draft EIR was expected to be quickly passed, except for one small glitch. The residents of Val Verde protested. They held a town meeting and voted unanimously against the expansion of the Chiquita Canyon Landfill.

Earlier the same day, flyers were passed out by John Musella (a contractor for the landfill and a registered lobbyist) with the topic sentence: “Don’t Let Them Take Your Money.” The kicker was, the flyer appeared to look like it came from Val Verde’s Civic Association. The town was so upset that on that night, they filled Val Verde Park’s only meeting building.

Since then, it has been a long and hard fight. Val Verde residents would like to hold the landfill accountable to the original contract made 20 years ago. The parties involved in the negotiations 20 years ago included the landfill owner, the county, and the Val Verde Civic Association. It would be the last expansion that Val Verde would have to endure.

Houses were sold in Val Verde with that same promise. “It is an iron-clad contract,” some Realtors would tell people buying houses in Val Verde.

Here is the glitch: Nothing is iron clad when the county is paid by the landfill.

The county is the one that must ensure the landfill closes, but that means a big loss of money for the county.

Since the first DEIR was written, many tactics have been tried to shut up Val Verde residents. A paper out of Stevenson Ranch has called for the arrest of those who complain about the stench in Val Verde. The reason they should be arrested is because they must be lying. The paper has also blamed the stench on septic tanks. Val Verde residents have been called bullies and compared to ISIS terrorists. The writer even posited that he drove through Val Verde and windows were open, so the townspeople must be liars. Believe me, on stinky days, windows are closed, and Val Verde residents become imprisoned in their houses waiting for the smells to pass.

Years ago, Castaic was looking for a new high school site. The first location they considered was Val Verde, but it was quickly eliminated. The same writer out of Stevenson Ranch wrote that they made an easy choice not to have the high school in plumes of stench from the dump. The dump does not smell now? Well, it really does, unless you are the paper in Stevenson Ranch, which is now majorly funded by the landfill.

At the last DEIR hearing, one individual called for Val Verde to have their septic tanks investigated. He stated homes should be taken away from anyone who does not have a house on at least two acres. It stands to reason if residents smell rotting garbage odors, it must be septic, not the 23 million tons of trash 800 feet from the first house in Val Verde. Of course, that same person tells Live Oak residents that sewers are to blame for the landfill smells that are carried on the winds.

Some in Val Verde have quit calling in smells to any authorities. They believe the inspections and threats that quickly followed their calls were related to their calling in the odor complaints. Some feel that they are just insulted by the landfill when they come out and walk up to a flower saying that the flower is the stench they are smelling. The truth is, they have been beaten down.

One resident overheard a county official demanding that someone from Animal Control be sent out to the farmer closest to the landfill. The thinking was that this farm must be the cause of the rotting trash smells. Members of the town were there to meet Animal Control when they showed up. The Animal Control officers did smell stench, as everyone present could. They even called SCAQMD in the presence of the town residents. The two officers stated that the strong odors were NOT from the farm, but from the landfill.

Many Val Verde residents believe that the landfill is affecting their health. Asthma attacks are frequent, along with other health problems. The house with the cancer marker in the first DEIR actually got cancer, so markers have been moved on the map.

The DEIR states that particulate matter of 2.5 and 10 will exceed health standards for the lifetime of the landfill. It has already exceeded up to this point. If residents are smelling the landfill, then they are also inhaling particulate matter and gases from the landfill. The county has been asked numerous times to do a door-to-door health survey on all the residents – just to be ignored.

The landfill hired a scientist to come out and check for smells. Those were some nice days in Val Verde. The landfill reps have admitted they knew when all testing would be done. It would be easy to figure out, on the days they tested, the landfill was extra careful to control its odors. Their scientist, however, did detect smells. The scientist concluded that Val Verde would get the odors from 6 percent to 9 percent of the day. Not all at once, but in small to large doses during the entire 24 hours as the wind shifted. At 6 percent, that would be 1 hour and 26 minutes a day, 37.8 hours a month, 453.6 hours a year.

In the final EIR are letters of endorsement. Most the letters are from those who have financial gain if the landfill remains open here. Many of the letters are from people and businesses that have been given donations from the landfill. Why they have submitted letters would make sense. What does not make sense are about 40 cards that were signed by residents of Val Verde. Well, it does make sense if you know the story. One of the mitigations the landfill must provide to Val Verde residents is four days a year of free drop-off dump service. On that day, those who spoke limited English were told they must sign cards to enter. They were concerned because in the past, they had never signed cards to dump on those days. The residents were informed it was a new procedure. The cards were actually endorsements for the landfill, written in English. Deceptive? Yes, but that is how it works when dealing with the landfill.

Is it possible that those who work at the landfill have become nose-blind to the odors? When the landfill got a citation from the SCAQMD for the stagnant odors in Val Verde, they had a reply: “Our operators did not notice the strong odors coming from the green waste.” If not for the citation, Val Verde residents would just be called liars again.

It is no small feat to get SCAQMD to come out. Most of the time Val Verde residents wait for hours, and when they show up, they cannot smell anything, as the wind has shifted. Many times SCAQMD doesn’t make it out to Val Verde at all.

The Val Verde Community Advisory Committee hired a scientist to come in and do their own testing. On the day the scientist was to show up, the landfill had hired him away from the VVCAC. Miraculously, a new scientist appeared. Some board members were not so keen on hiring him, but the sitting president insisted he was the right choice. Of course, the sitting president has a letter endorsing the landfill on file. The new scientist found this landfill to be amazing. He also informed the landfill of all days he would be testing. The new scientist informed Val Verde residents that all water wells were clean. When asked how he came to that conclusion, he responded that he interviewed the landfill. The last well reports state that wells 8, 16, 18 and 20 exceeded control limits.

It comes down to this. Promises should be kept, and the landfill should be closed down once and for all. Val Verde, along with all of the Santa Clarita Valley, deserves cleaner air. Thirty more years of business as usual should not be allowed. The DEIR listed many alternatives. All alternatives except for one stated the landfill would exceed many health standards for years to come. Only one standard that they listed would be the “superior alternative.” The superior alternative would make the air cleaner for all of Santa Clarita.

“18.5 Environmentally Superior Alternative:

“From among the alternatives evaluated, CEQA requires that a Draft EIR identify the environmentally superior alternative. Based on the discussion of the various alternatives, the environmentally superior alternative is Alternative A, the No Project Alternative. Under the No Project Alternative, the landfill operation would continue according to existing conditions only until July 31, 2017. While Alternative A could shift many of the daily operation impacts from one facility to another, the No Project Alternative involves no construction and would not directly involve any development or the disturbance of resources at CCL, unlike Alternatives B and C. Therefore, the No Project Alternative would be the Environmentally Superior Alternative, although it would not achieve the Project objectives.”

Quoted directly from the Draft EIR.

You might ask what you can do as an ordinary citizen, not involved in the fight, but concerned about air quality in your valley. You can call, write and e-mail. Say, “I oppose the Chiquita Canyon Landfill Expansion.”

Reference: Project #R2004-00559-(5); Conditional Use Permit #2004-00042 See the Notice of Public Hearing (English and Spanish) at http://bit.ly/2lFiZ2K.


Five Los Angeles County Supervisors

Kathryn Barger (213) 974-5555

Janice Hahn (213) 974-4444

Sheila Kuehl (213) 974-3333

Mark Ridley-Thomas (213) 974-2222

Hilda L. Solis (213) 974-4111

Kenneth Hahn Hall of Administration

500 W. Temple Street

Los Angeles, CA 90012


Los Angeles County Department of Regional Planning (planning.lacounty.gov)

(213) 974-6443

320 West Temple Street, 13th Floor

Los Angeles, CA 90012






Steve Lee is an asthmatic resident of Val Verde.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


  1. Caroline Trujillo says:

    Thursday is March 2nd, which date is it?

  2. Michael says:

    Thanks Steve for explaining how so called liberal leaders in the county, and state, really take care of the people…feel the love people?
    Our leaders are simple thieves. Ridley is the worst of these…by a large margin.

  3. Steve says:

    Sorry it is Wednesday March 1st.

  4. Susie Evans says:

    The hearing on the final environmental impact report for the expansion of the Chiquita Canyon Landfill will be held Thursday, March 1, at Rancho Pico Jr. High School, 26250 Valencia Blvd., from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m. There is an alternative, Mesquite Landfill, paid for by LA County taxes!

  5. Tanya says:

    Carolyn, it is Wednesday, March 1st.

  6. Tanya says:

    SCVTV, could you please change the word “Thursday” to “Wednesday” in the fourth line of the article? Thank you. Tanya

  7. Susie Evans says:


  8. Richard Hood says:

    Called or emailed them all – took 5 minutes. Good job Steve.

Leave a Comment

Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
Thursday, Jul 20, 2017
Much of the dramatic decline of the yellow-billed cuckoo in California has been directly attributed to breeding habitat loss and degradation from lands being converted to agricultural and other urban uses.
Wednesday, Jul 19, 2017
The Newhall Ranch project will create nearly 74,000 permanent jobs within the region and an estimated 130,000 construction jobs over the decades it will take to build the project, and it will provide a variety of housing types from apartments and starter homes to places to raise a family, from affordable housing to executive housing.
Friday, Jul 14, 2017
Medicare covers a variety of heath care services that you can get in the comfort and privacy of your home. These include intermittent skilled nursing care, physical therapy, speech-language pathology services, and occupational therapy.
Tuesday, Jul 11, 2017
In their attempt to usurp the Division of State Architect's role in the reopening of Acton School, the Acton-Agua Dulce school board has exposed itself to possible penalties being levied against the district, or civil lawsuits against individual board members.
Sunday, Jul 9, 2017
Python hunters work in pairs. One is the puller and one is the “hole guy.” The hole guy crawls into the hole to face the python head-on. When he’s bitten and the snake is holding on tight, the puller pulls out the hole guy, and the snake comes out with him.
Wednesday, Jul 5, 2017
As the temperatures go up this week, a great way to cool off is to head to one of the City’s six pools, says Santa Clarita City Manager Ken Striplin.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1915 - Pioneer Juan Batista Suraco buried in a family graveyard, currently unmarked, in Bouquet Canyon near Benz Road [story]
The Los Angeles Dodgers Monday reinstated left-handed pitcher Hyun-Jin Ryu from the 10-day disabled list, put Clayton Kershaw on the DL with low back strain, among other roster moves.
Dodgers Roster Moves: Kershaw & McCarthy on DL, Ryu Reinstated
Sierra Bancorp, parent of Bank of the Sierra, today announced its unaudited financial results for the three- and six-month periods ended June 30, 2017.
Sierra Bancorp Reports Earnings for First Half of 2017
Marston's restaurant in Valencia will donate 20 percent of patrons' bills for breakfast, lunch or dinner to the fundraising effort for the new Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center on Tuesday, July 25.
July 25: Dine at Marston’s, Benefit New SCV Senior Center
The county of Los Angeles seeks to block reopening of the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage field until an earthquake analysis is completed.
L.A. County Moves to Block Aliso Gas Field Reopening
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, COC's MakerSpaces received a grant to enhance their centers on both campuses. Plus, the L.A. SummerFEST needs your help. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Monday, July 24, 2017
Here's a preview of Santa Clarita arts-related events for July 26-28, 2017.
July 26-28: Santa Clarita Arts Calendar
Alfredo Manzano is the new head coach of the Saugus boys basketball program, Saugus High School Principal Vince Ferry announced today.
Manzano Named New Saugus Boys Basketball Coach
College of the Canyons has been awarded a $311,432 grant to enhance its MakerSpace centers at both COC campuses with additional equipment, courses, training and internships.
COC ‘MakerSpace’ Centers Awarded $311,432 Grant
Organizers of the non-profit Santa Clarita Festival are seeking the community's help to cover a funding shortfall for the the ninth annual L.A. SummerFEST, a cultural festival featuring free performances of Shakespeare’s plays.
L.A. SummerFEST Seeks Donations to Keep Shakespeare Onstage
The city of Santa Clarita’s New Heights Artist Development Series offers free local workshops, panel discussions and lectures designed specifically with the creative individual in mind.
New Heights Artist Development Series Fosters Creative Growth
Wolf Creek Brewery will host a "Pints & Paws" fundraiser at Wolf Creek Brewery to benefit the SCV Education Foundation on Tuesday, July 25 starting at 4 p.m.
July 25: Pints & Paws Fundraiser for SCV Education Foundation
A GoFundMe crowdfunding page has been set up to help cover funeral expenses for a mother and two of her children killed in a rollover crash on Highway 14 in Acton Thursday.
Funeral Expenses Fund Set Up for 3 Dead in Acton Rollover Crash
Mylz Jones, Collin Ferguson and Yonathan Daza each delivered four hits to help lift the JetHawks over the Lake Elsinore Storm, 14-8, on Sunday evening at The Hangar.
JetHawks Power Through Storm 14-8 Sunday
The Lancaster JetHawks combined for 13 runs in the fourth and fifth innings and cruised to a 14-3 victory over the Lake Elsinore Storm on Saturday night at The Hangar.
Two Huge Innings Lift JetHawks to Blowout Win Saturday
Garrett Hampson delivered three hits and drove in four to lead the Lancaster JetHawks over the Lake Elsinore Storm, 10-7, on Friday night at The Hangar.
Hampson Helps ‘Hawks Weather Storm, Even Series Friday
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has awarded more than $12 million to California and 22 more states plus the District of Columbia to support their responses to the opioid overdose epidemic.
CDC Awards $12 Million to California, 22 More States to Fight Opioid Epidemic
The California Department of Water Resources is seeking validation of $11 billion in bonds to fund Gov. Jerry Brown’s Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta tunnel project, California Water Fix, which cleared its final environmental hurdle on Friday.
California Sues to Validate Bonds to Fund Delta Tunnels Project
The Castaic Lake Water Agency's Planning and Engineering Committee has scheduled a meeting for Tuesday, August 1 starting at 5:30 p.m.
August 1: CLWA Planning & Engineering Meeting
A suspect in a fatal hit and run collision in Lancaster on Tuesday morning turned himself in to authorities Friday evening.
Suspect in Fatal Hit & Run Crash Surrenders
The sweltering “dog days” of summer can harm household pets, and the Army Public Health Center has some tips to avoid heat-related health problems.
Sweltering ‘Dog Days’ of Summer Dangerous for Household Pets
Only one crime in the Castaic-Val Verde area (Zone 2) was reported to the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station for the week of July 10.
Crime Blotter: Thief Steals TV from Inn in Castaic
1864 - Walker/Reynier family patriarch Jean Joseph Reynier, then 15, arrives in Sand Canyon from France; eventually homesteads 1,200 acres [story]
1982 - Vic Morrow & two child actors killed in helicopter crash at Indian Dunes during filming of "Twilight Zone: The Movie" [story]
Multiple award-winning songwriter, singer and actor Kris Kristofferson is scheduled to appear at the new Canyon Club Santa Clarita at Westfield Valencia Town Center Mall on Thursday night, January 4, 2018.
January 4: Kris Kristofferson at Canyon Santa Clarita
2000 - Historic Larinan house in Pico Canyon burns down [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, two children are still in critical condition after yesterday's rollover crash. Plus, deputies arrested an underage DUI suspect whose vehicle smashed into a traffic signal after a collision in Canyon Country. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, July 21, 2017
A second child has died and two other children are in critical condition after a rollover crash on the 14 freeway near Acton Thursday morning killed an infant, CHP officials said.
Second Child Dies, 2 Still Critical after Acton Crash
World-renowned artist John Moffitt will headline the ARTree's Speaker Series with a talk at The MAIN on Main Street in Old Town Newhall on Thursday, July 27 starting at 7 p.m.
July 27: John Moffitt Headlines ARTree Speaker Series
Registration is now open for the ARTree Community Arts Center's fall children's art sampler class, which begins September 22 at the center in Newhall.
July 25: Fall ARTree Children’s Art Class Registration Opens
The 21st annual "Heart of the West" fundraiser for the non-profit Carousel Ranch horse therapy program for children will take place at the ranch on Saturday, August 26 starting at 6 p.m.
August 26: ‘Heart of the West’ to Benefit Carousel Ranch
The California State Transportation Agency and the Department of Transportation today announced the fast tracking of “fix it first” construction work and increased road repairs across the state.
State Transportation Leaders Expedite Millions in SB 1 Road Repairs
Registration has begun for the fall 2017 semester at College of the Canyons, which offers more than 1,900 class sections in a wide range of academic subjects and career education disciplines.
COC Fall 2017 Registration Under Way
Former Los Angeles County Sheriff Lee Baca has been denied bond pending the appeal of his conviction for obstructing a federal investigation into county jails.
Ex-L.A. County Sheriff Lee Baca Denied Bond Ahead of Conviction Appeal
The number of reported Valley Fever infections in Los Angeles County increased by 37 percent in 2016 compared to 2015, according to a news release from the county Department of Public Health.
Valley Fever Cases Up 37 Percent in L.A. County
A multi-vehicle collision in Canyon Country led deputies to arrest an underage DUI suspect who also crashed into a traffic signal around 5:30 a.m. Friday.
20-Year-Old Arrested on Suspicion of DUI After Canyon Country Crash