[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Mostly clear
Mostly clear
55°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
December 8
1941 - Julius Dietzmann family of Castaic arrested as German enemy aliens [story]


OAKLAND – In a federal courtroom in Oakland, California, on Wednesday, the Department of Justice clashed with lawyers for the Sierra Club, the state of California and a slew of other states looking to block the Pentagon from diverting $3.6 billion from the military to build a southern border wall.

Justice Department attorney James Burnham told U.S. District Judge Haywood Gilliam that proposed border barriers in California, New Mexico and Arizona are covered by 10 U.S. Code § 2808, which allows the Department of Defense, in the event of a national emergency requiring the armed forces, to spend military construction funds on projects necessary to support the armed forces.

Burnham said several thousand military personnel are already at the border to help law enforcement with the Department of Homeland Security to deter illegal entry into the United States.

“How would you articulate the argument for why this construction is necessary to support the armed forces?” Gilliam asked Burnham.

“Based on the evidence, the installation of barriers will lessen the burdens on those troops and allow them to do other things. Or maybe obviate the need for them,” he answered.

Burnham said the land is also clearly under the military’s jurisdiction, since it was transferred to the Defense Department by the Department of Interior. In October 2019, the Secretary of the Army then assigned all land needed for the projects to U.S. Army Garrison Fort Bliss, Texas, making them part of that military installation.

Burnham said this further bolsters the argument that the wall projects are “military construction” for the purposes of § 2808.

And he noted a portion of the proposed border wall in Arizona is already part of the Goldwater Range, a 70-mile bomb testing site southeast of Yuma that extends all the way to the Sonoran Desert National Monument.

Gilliam said he was curious whether land in other states can actually be assigned to Fort Bliss, and if the government is actually allowed to create a “military installation” by transferring land to the Department of Defense. He asked Burnham for further briefing on these issues by noon next Monday.

Megan Barbero with the General Counsel’s Office for the U.S. House of Representatives called Burnham’s reasoning about Fort Bliss “not a good faith reading of § 2808,” and said the Trump administration was using it “to circumvent an appropriation by claiming the land is a military installation.”

Gilliam also seemed to take exception to Burnham’s contention that it is up to the Secretary of Defense to decide whether a project is necessary to support the use of the armed forces.

“Why can’t a court review the asserted basis – with some deference or great deference or whatever the standard is – and make a determination as to whether on its face it suffices?” Gilliam asked. “It sounds like you’re saying the assertion is unchallengeable by anyone.”

Burnham answered, “It is just the kind of military judgment that courts don’t review and Congress has not given courts the authority to review.” He added that “if the court were to go there, then there would be extraordinary deference due.”

In addition to the Sierra Club, California – along with Colorado, Hawaii, Maryland, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Virginia, and Wisconsin – sued to stop the funds from being moved around. They claim the Department of Defense overstepped its authority by trying to circumvent Congress, which refused to allocate more than $1.375 billion for border security in January 2019 after a month-long government shutdown.

Arguing for the Sierra Club, ACLU attorney Dror Ladin said the president’s declaration of a national emergency at the border was an unprecedented move designed to bypass Congress’ authority to appropriate funding for the border wall.

“There are so many ways in which what’s happening here is unlike anything that has ever happened,” Ladin said – from President Donald Trump’s national emergency determination to the Defense Department’s “novel theories of what a military installation might be.”

Ladin said border security falls under the purview of the Department of Homeland Security, a civilian law enforcement agency, and it cannot use military funding to support its operations.

He said § 2808 contemplates an emergency situation in which Congress would be unable to appropriate funding for necessary military construction.

“For the president to say, ‘How about if I use it if I disagree with an appropriations decision’ is completely opposed to the purpose and function of 2808,” Ladin said.

The Sierra Club also says the border wall projects will harm local wildlife and detract from their members’ enjoyment of the natural landscape. Ladin said 93% of the Goldwater Range is designated as a wilderness area, adding, “It’s not this missile-cratered expanse on the border it is being claimed to be.”

Justice Department attorney Eric Grant disputed the Sierra Club’s claims, saying not a single western burrowing owl, checkerspot butterfly, or vernal pool species will be disturbed by the projects.

Gilliam took the arguments under submission and said he will try to rule soon on whether the cases survive summary judgment.

The Ninth Circuit is still weighing whether to overturn an injunction barring the use of $2.5 billion in Pentagon funds for the border wall under § 8005 of the Department of Defense Appropriations Act.

— By Mario Dinzeo

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, Dec 6, 2019
Wind Chill Cold Weather Alert Called for AV, Local Mountains
Due to the National Weather Service’s forecast for wind chill temperatures, the Los Angeles County Health Officer on Friday called a cold weather alert for the Antelope Valley and LA County mountain areas.
Friday, Dec 6, 2019
Second of 2 Robbery Suspects Arrested
The second of two robbery suspects who initially eluded deputies during containment of a Canyon Country neighborhood Tuesday afternoon has been arrested, sheriff’s officials said.
Friday, Dec 6, 2019
Planners to Weigh Extending Plan for Senior Condo Complex
For each of the past six years, developers planning to build a senior condo complex near Towsley Canyon on The Old Road have asked regional planners for more time to keep the project alive, and on Tuesday they’ll ask again.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1941 - Julius Dietzmann family of Castaic arrested as German enemy aliens [story]
1921 - William S. Hart marries actress Winifred Westover [story]
Bill and Winifred Hart
Due to the National Weather Service’s forecast for wind chill temperatures, the Los Angeles County Health Officer on Friday called a cold weather alert for the Antelope Valley and LA County mountain areas.
Wind Chill Cold Weather Alert Called for AV, Local Mountains
Every Thursday in Stevenson Ranch, one can see a classroom full of Pico Elementary special education children eagerly dancing their way down the street or gleefully visiting a grocery store en masse.
Pico Elementary Special Ed Classroom Gifted Field Trips, Stroller
Valencia-based nonprofit organization SNAP Sports is proud to announce a new partnership with Afterburn Fitness in Valencia to help train special-needs athletes for hockey festival competition.
SNAP Sports, Afterburn Fitness Team for Hockey Training
The city of Santa Clarita and the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station are teaming up for the latest iteration of the "Heads Up" traffic safety campaign, just in time for the year-end holidays.
City, Deputies Team for Holiday ‘Heads Up’ DUI Safety Campaign
The second of two robbery suspects who initially eluded deputies during containment of a Canyon Country neighborhood Tuesday afternoon has been arrested, sheriff’s officials said.
Second of 2 Robbery Suspects Arrested
Castaic Middle School KLAWS clubs in partnership with West Ranch High School and DFYinSCV will carol to the adoptable pets at the Castaic Animal Care & Control Center on Thursday, December 19, from 4 p.m. to 5 p.m.
Dec. 19: KLAWS Clubs to Carol for Shelter Pets Awaiting Adoption
Libbie McMahan scored half the points for her team in Saugus High School girls basketball’s 56-51 tournament win over Glendora at Sierra Canyon on Thursday night.
McMahan Scores 31 as Saugus Girls Hoops Beats Glendora
The Golden Valley High School Grizzly Band, Jazz Band and Color Guard have set a benefit event for Saugus High School at Tomato Joe's Pizza & Taps on Wednesday, December 11 from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Dec. 11: Grizzlies to Stage Benefit for Saugus High at Tomato Joe’s
Although they might be training to become master chefs, no one is above having fun with a gingerbread house competition during the holiday season.
COC Culinary Institute Holds Annual Gingerbread House Competition
For each of the past six years, developers planning to build a senior condo complex near Towsley Canyon on The Old Road have asked regional planners for more time to keep the project alive, and on Tuesday they’ll ask again.
Planners to Weigh Extending Plan for Senior Condo Complex
With the new year just weeks away, the Santa Clarita City Council is set to nominate its new 2020 mayor on Tuesday.
Santa Clarita City Council to Appoint 2020 Mayor
1864 - Actor William S. Hart born in Newburgh, New York [Hart Index]
Wm. S. Hart
The Santa Clarita Arts Commission will hold its regular meeting Thursday, Dec. 12, 6:30 p.m.
Dec. 12: Arts Commission Regular Meeting
A special meeting of the Engineering & Operations Committee is scheduled to meet on Monday, Dec. 9, at 5:30 p.m. at Summit Circle, located at 26521 Summit Circle, Santa Clarita, in the Training Room.
Dec. 9: SCV Water Engineering & Operations Committee Special Meeting
Because of the recent rainfall, Los Angeles County Health Officer, Muntu Davis, MD, MPH, is cautioning residents who are planning to visit Los Angeles County beaches to avoid swimming, surfing, and playing in ocean waters around discharging storm drains, creeks, and rivers. Bacteria, chemicals, debris, trash, and other public health hazards from city streets and mountain areas are likely to contaminate ocean waters at and around these outlets after a rainfall.
Water Advisory Issued for Los Angeles County Beaches
OAKLAND — Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara issued a mandatory one-year moratorium Thursday on insurance companies non-renewing policyholders - helping at least 800,000 homes in wildfire disaster areas in Northern and Southern California.
Insurers Now Banned from Pulling Policies in CA’s Fire-Ravaged Areas
In what has become a Newhall tradition, Faith Community Church will welcome the neighborhood to celebrate Christmas with its 14th annual “Festividad for Christ” event.
Dec. 14: Annual “Festividad for Christ” at Faith Community Church
The Santa Clarita Valley Youth Orchestra (SCVYO) invites all young musicians to attend the next “Visiting Artists Program” workshop that will be taking place Saturday, Dec. 7, from 10:00 a.m. – 12:30 p.m. in Pico Canyon Hall at College of the Canyons.
Dec. 7: SCV Youth Orchestra’s “Visiting Artists Program” Workshop
As the community continues to process the Saugus High School tragedy and find comfort in one another, the Santa Clarita Public Library has come together with Homes4Families to offer Santa Clarita teens and tweens affected by the shooting a healing art program, titled “The Heart of Feeling: Emotions Hidden Inside.”
Dec. 11: “The Heart of Feeling” Healing Art Program at Santa Clarita Library
Four Santa Clarita Valley volleyball players were named to an All-CIF team, as announced by the CIF-Southern Section on Monday.
Volleyball Players from 3 SCV Schools Named ALL-CIF
Preparations are underway for the eighth annual SCV Charity Chili Cook-off, and organizers are looking for sponsors and chili cooker contestants.
Annual Charity Chili Cook-Off Looking for Sponsors, Contestants
The Newhall residential community is about to grow with the addition of nearly 100 condominiums after the Santa Clarita Planning Commission approved their construction on Tuesday.
Planning Commission Approves Condominium Project on Dockweiler Drive
%d bloggers like this: