header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
March 18
1919 - Fire destroys abandoned second Southern Hotel, built 1878 in Newhall (corner Main & Market) [story]
Second Southern Hotel


Commentary by Steve Lee
| Tuesday, Jan 6, 2015
stevelee_valverde
Seriously. Bullies?

steveleeI asked a few of my fellow bullies here in Val Verde to come and have their pictures taken. I wanted the rest of the Santa Clarita Valley, Los Angeles County and all who care to see some of the faces of those fighting for their health here in Val Verde.

The Chiquita Canyon Landfill representative said in a radio interview, “We will not be bullied.” The company with a $44 million profit per quarter is bullied by Val Verde?

Are they being bullied? Is it a bully who says:

1. Please keep your contract that was made with us 19 years ago and close down.

2. We want the Chiquita Canyon Landfill to stop looking for loopholes, just keep your word and walk away like we were promised in writing many years ago.

3. We don’t want anything in Chiquita Canyon landfill that could harm us or our children.

4. We do not want to live next to a landfill that will run 24 hours a day instead of zero (0) hours, as promised, after 2019.

5. We do not want to be buried in traffic as 400 trucks and cars come into your landfill every hour of every day.

6. We do not want to be in the “chronic” range on the EPA table.

7. We want our friends, children and families to be with us for years down the road.

8. We do not want to have to look for medication in the middle of the night so we can get a less obstructed breath.

9. We do not want to spend more on medication for our children, ourselves or our families so the Chiquita Canyon Landfill can rake in huge profits.

10. We do not want to have to close our windows and pay high cooling costs because Chiquita Canyon Landfill cannot control the stench.

11. We don’t want to live next to a landfill whose liners failed during the last major earthquake – the only landfill liners to fail in all of Los Angeles.

12. We do not want our breathing of fresh air obstructed just because buying sand for cover instead of Green Waste would cut into your profits.

13. We do not want to be despised buy our neighbors just because we cannot be bought with bikes, donations, or flat-out plain money.

14. We do not want “safe” dirt from Rocketdyne to be put into this landfill. If it is safe, then why not leave it where it is? Why the special containers to transport it?

15. We don’t want to keep finding articles on the sludge, toxic waste or radioactive material dumped in your landfill.

16. We do not want to sit by while Chiquita Canyon spends money buying our neighbors because it is much cheaper than fixing the problem to control the odors.

17. We don’t want to see the representative from the landfill calling us bullies in interviews on a radio station that receives advertising dollars from the landfill.

18. Stop taking in tainted soil from LAUSD (http://notebook.lausd.net/pls/ptl/docs/PAGE/CA_LAUSD/FLDR_ORGANIZATIONS/FLDR_OIG_PUBLICATIONS_CONTRACT_AUDIT_REPORTS/CA%2009-723.PDF)

19. No more contaminated soil from anywhere.

CCL received contaminated soil from the Malibu High School/Middle School have been sent to CCL. Here is a link to this news story: http://www.laweekly.com/2014-03-20/news/cancer-scare-at-malibu-high-turns-messy/

The soil is contaminated with PCBs and other carcinogens (http://www.malibutimes.com/news/article_47b7705c-2a1a-11e4-a87a-001a4bcf887a.html)

Here is the report where they state they sent the soil to CCL: http://fipcontractors.smmusd.org/Data/Sites/6/documents/malibupublicnotice/removalactioncompletionreport-1.pdf

(Nos. 18 and 19 came to my attention from a concerned citizen here in Val Verde while I was writing this article.)

Excerpt from the report:

A) “All excavated pesticide- and/or PCB affected soils were transported to the Chiquita Canyon Landfill in Castaic, California. A total of 48 truckloads of pesticide- and/or PCB-affected soil were removed from the Site and transported to this landfill. Copies of soil shipping documents, including the waste profile, are provided in Appendix C.”

B) CCL bid on contaminated soil from a clean-up of the Madrona Marsh. The soil contained petroleum hydrocarbons which were classified as “non-hazardous” (http://www.torranceca.gov/PDF/MadronaMarshSumpDredgingProjectFinalResultsofSoilCharacterization2-4-2013.pdf).

Is it being a bully to ask for these things? Are we asking too much? Would others in our situation ask for the same, or more? Does standing up for your rights make you a bully? Then I guess we are bullies.

All of us from age 1 to 80 from Val Verde are to be feared throughout all of Santa Clarita Valley. Hopefully for everyone else in the Santa Clarita Valley we are not let out of our confinement of stench to wander the streets.

 

Steve Lee is a Val Verde resident.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

24 Comments

  1. Steven Aune says:

    The landfill has been there for over 40 years. Unless you moved in before 1972 you chose to move next to the dump. You still put your trash out front for collecting. Where do you think it goes? Like it or not waste needs to go somewhere. This is like moving next to LAX and complaining about the noise. SMH.

    • Steven — Many people who moved here after 1972, like our family that moved here 5 1/2 years ago, did with an understanding that there would be proper air monitoring, that the landfill would comply with all existing regulations (which it hasn’t) and that the landfill would close in 2019.

      What is upsetting residents right now is that the landfill has violated various regulations by taking in materials it previously agreed to not take in (per its agreement with the community), not providing anything in regards to air monitoring and (this last one is the biggest issue) that the landfill is now seeking to expand, rather than close in 2019. They want to double their expansion, in fact.

      Personally, as a member of the community of Val Verde who is working to see the landfill close, this experience has made me extremely mindful of my waste and I work hard to reduce my waste. I compost and take other measures to reduce my waste. Plus, much of the trash that the landfill takes in (and most of the trash that it will take in if it doubles its capacity) does not come from our tiny town of about 2,000 residents. It comes from elsewhere.

      We understand that waste needs to go somewhere, but do not think that this fact makes it okay for the landfill to violate its original agreement by doubling its capacity rather than closing.

    • Bonnie Nikolai says:

      Just because we were aware of the dump, doesn’t mean we were aware of the dangers of living next to a landfill. I know I didn’t realize how close my house was until 6 months ago. The entrance is 4 miles away from me, but the borders are only 1.5 miles. Living within 2 miles of a landfill is dangerous according to studies in the National Institute of Health database. The fact remains, no corporation should be able to come in to an already established town and make it dangerous to live in. There are many families in Val Verde who have lived here since before the landfill existed. Chiquita has had violations on methane, taking toxic waste and Chiquita signed a contract with Val Verde to close no later than November 24, 2019. We expect that contract to be upheld. This landfill will be bigger than Disneyland if allowed to expand. Let that sink in for a moment.

    • Brandi Howse says:

      We Barb Green and Steven Aune moved to the area with the understanding that the landfill was closing. That is what we were promised in writing, in a contract. We were also told it was an odorless landfill and that nothing unsafe was ever dumped there. These of course we have come to find out are all lies. We have every right to be angry about the landfill not keeping the promises it made to our community. And yes we have absolute proof that things have been dumped illegally as well as a copy of the contract with our community.
      Furthermore it is one thing when you smell things quite another when 5 minutes after smelling the stench that you throat starts to get scratchy and sinus start to burn and you all of a sudden have a horrible headache. Did you know they were caught dumping sludge? Did you know there has been dirt sent here from Rockedyne? All we are asking them is to please honor your promises to our community. How is that asking to much???

    • Andrea Provenzale says:

      Enough with the “SMH” and silly remarks that the landfill was there first. Just because there is a landfill next to your community does to mean it gets to be run in a manner that is a nuisance to the community, as well as accept toxic waste that another community does not want. We all know that until the United States adopts a better way of dealing with our waste than burying it in the ground, it will have to go somewhere. That does not mean that the landfill owners and operators in California get a free pass to cut corners. Plans were in place to close that landfill when people purchased or rented their home. If a city or county wants to change it up, they should take measures to protect the community, and/or compensate them. It is unfortunate that the citizens have to police the people that are said to be policing the landfills.

      • SCVNews.com says:

        There used to be a lot of hog farms out here, but then the hog farmers decided to make more money buy building homes and attracting home buyers, so they got rid of the hogs. Newhall Land used to own a landfill (Chiquita), but then it decided it wanted to make more money by building more homes and attracting more home buyers, so it got rid of the landfill. (It sold it, with a written guarantee that it would close no later than November 2019.)

  2. Steven Lee says:

    Steven Aune the landfill contract says they will close down. Are you saying contracts should not be honored. 20% of this landfill is from Santa Clarita Valley. Do you think all the hazardous waste, toxic waste, and other harmful chemicals should be allowed? Also violations of the contract. Trash is coming from hundreds of miles, they pass many landfills to get here. They have to pass the other landfills, because they will not take the dangers on those trucks. So, you are saying poison your neighbors,maybe even Santa Clarita itself, due to dangers carried on the wind, as long as you have a place for your trash.

  3. Barb Green says:

    I don’t get it, you moved to a location that has a dump, you knew it was there and bought anyways? Just like those who move by the airports and then want the planes to stop flying.

  4. Barb – Please also see the comment above that I shared with Steven.

  5. msc545 says:

    I can’t tell if the people who made the airport analogies are just stupid, paid shills for the landfill, or both. The airport may annoy people but it doesn’t poison them, and it isn’t expanding far beyond what was originally agreed on, and it isn’t engaging dangerous prohibited activities. The dump is doing all of this.

    If this is your best argument for letting thelandfill do what it wants perhaps you should rethink the whole thing because you aren’t making sense. Comparing apples to oranges rarely does

  6. Steven Lee says:

    Barb, we are fighting an expansion. It is in most of our closing papers. There will be no more expansions. 42 years is enough burden for a neighborhood. It was the contract that the landfill did 19 years ago. If you let us do 19 years more, than we will not expand anymore. We are asking them to keep their contract. Barb are contracts to be honored? I do not get how a contract is not to be honored. I still make my house payment, and in 27 more years I will make no more. That is the contract. Should they change it on year 26?

  7. Steven H says:

    Thanks for the write up Steve. To those who say you should’ve known better. When I moved to Val Verde in ’97 I was told by the landfill, my realtor and the community board that the landfill was closing down then, (but they expanded fortunately with a contract to close in 2019) I did my research, I was also told that the landfill was a great neighbor helping the community and there were no problems, no odors, no cause for concern. So I bought my house poured every cent I had and borrowed more to move here. Then I learned the truth Steve talks about. Now I am stuck in a house and can’t afford to move I thought I could just hold on til 2019 when they would close for good and now they aren’t. What if you bought a house near LAX and they changed a flight pattern to take off right over your house after you were promised that would never happen you live in a “protected area”? Would you be upset?

  8. As pointed out by Steve, the landfill signed a contract that said it was to close by 2019 or when it reaches the agreed upon capacity. Steve also points out that the landfill has been accepting toxic and contaminated substances that aren’t permitted. The landfill wants to expand over 13 stories higher. Currently, the landfill can’t control odors at the level and rate they are operating at. Do you want 400 extra trucks and cars per hour going through the area? Does it make sense to expand, so CCL can take in trash from all over LA or should the landfill be held to their agreement? Do we really want one of the country’s largest landfills to continue to operate for the next 30 years in this area or is the $$$ that important?

  9. Actually I did not know I bought a house next to a dump. After I found out, I thought the dump would end according to plan, so I thought I could live with it, given it would be over pretty soon. I didn’t realize how bad it was until I started going door to door over by Lincoln Avenue taking a health survey. I had to quit after two hours, because the smell was making me sick, and almost everyone I interviewed had health problems. Just because we moved next to a dump doesn’t mean that we haven’t done our time or that we have to like it forever. Let’s trade places. It’s time for another neighborhood to take the trash. How about the desert?

  10. Sara Sage says:

    You guys aren’t racist at all…

  11. Kevan Smalley says:

    When some idiot says “You knew it was there when you bought your home” I shouldn’t have to explain that I bought my home in 87′ with the knowledge that the landfill would be closing in 97′. I figured I could live with it until it closed which was supposed to 15 years ago.

  12. Kevan Smalley says:

    Steve, I see you still have your stalker!

  13. Steven Lee says:

    The one who took the video was the acting president of the VVCAC. A personal friend of the landfill representative. Was the board stacked against Val Verde? Who knows. While she was acting president she belittled all who attended if they disagreed with the landfill. She showed up at Castaic Town Council meetings and shouted out during some of the residents 3 minute shares. She laughed at us,and yet we went on. The entire time she said she was neutral, as she took surnames on this site to call people names, only those opposed to the landfill. Some members of the Castaic Town Council for four months said, “Same tired faces.” We still grew in numbers at each consecutive meeting. The president would constantly interrupt the 3 minute shares, so the 3 minutes were basically taken away. You have to talk fast to get in all the information.That day we had buses lined up to take those without cars. The Castaic Town Council sent word that the landfill was not on the agenda at all. We cancelled all buses, but a good 27 of us went. Well I went because I did not trust the town council. I was right, the entire night was basically the agreement with the landfill. The president said, “your people should have shown up, where are they.” Knowing that they sent out word for them not to come. Madam president of the last VVCAC board I hope they post the video here once again. It shows the anger of a community fighting for all the communities within the stench of the landfill.

  14. Dena says:

    We were lied to by the Landfill (and Realtor by the way), and I did do research when buying our home in 1999. We were assured by the Chiquita that there were no adverse effects from the landfill and that it would be closed by 2019 or possibly before that if it ran over capacity. Now they want to break the contract they agreed to and expand while it has become more and more evident that there are indeed adverse effects on Val Verde residents. A plethora of health related issues as well as bad odors that I don’t recall smelling years ago. But, we sure do now! In my household alone we’ve two adults that have been diagnosed with Autoimmune as well as Pulmonary disease just years after having moved here. Coincidence? I don’t think so… We were lied to, plain and simple. No doubt about it. I don’t care how many “free dump days” we’re offered or sports team uniforms or bicycles, or any bribes in monies offered, etc… by the landfill. Health concerns are of the utmost importance. In the meantime, our property values will also plummet… The landfill needs to put persons over profit!

  15. Greg Kimura says:

    If the management of the landfill was being honorable, there would be very little to argue about, however that isn’t the case. Here are some facts for everyone here to consider:

    1. Contract with Val Verde says no sludge can be brought in.
    2. County operating permit says no sludge can be brought in.
    3. Management of the landfill bid on numerous sludge contracts.
    4. Management of the landfill signed a contract to accept sludge and took it in.
    5. The only reason they stopped taking it in was due to a resident who found the information on her own.
    6. The landfill management continued to deny the sludge issue, until proof that we knew about it was presented to them.
    7. Even after the proof was presented, the managers tried to downgrade it by calling it another name.
    8. The federal government, state government, county government and the landfill’s own website say that that junk they took in was sludge.
    9. The landfill managers denied using green waste anywhere in the landfill.
    10. The residents smelled a horrible odor last month and lo and behold it was from green waste.
    11. When one of the managers was confronted by this information, he denied that they said they don’t use green waste.
    12. The original denial was at a meeting and has been confirmed.
    13. The landfill is required to hold a community dump day 4X per year, per the contract with Val Verde and their use permit.
    14. At the last dump day event, they unilaterally added a new requirement – residents had to meet with landfill reps and management to discuss the landfill expansion.
    15. Some of the residents don’t speak English, so they were tricked into signing a landfill expansion approval card.
    16. When this was brought to the attention of the landfill management, the community asked for them to destroy the cards, due the the deceptive manner they were obtained.
    17. At the last VVCAC meeting, I asked the manager of the landfill to destroy the cards and to give the residents a formal apology.
    18. Instead, the landfill manager stated that they intend to send the cards to the county to show that the residents support the expansion.

  16. Greg Kimura says:

    There is a lot of fear in our community, regarding the operation of the landfill. The landfill has hidden too much from us and we have no idea how bad things really are. There are many residents who have symptoms similar to toxic poisoning – the same toxins which come from landfills. The residents who live closest to the landfill have the highest incidence of illness. The landfill managers told the residents that the odors are not coming from the landfill, but are from their neighbors trash can, septic tank, dead animals, a local ranch and even from a flower. On only one occasion can I remember the landfill admitting fault and that was when they received a Notice of Violation. I am pleased that they did, but the question remains; how can the residents of Val Verde trust what the managers of the landfill tell us?

  17. David Salinas says:

    I think Bonnie hit the nail on the head with this comment..”Living within 2 miles of a landfill is dangerous according to studies in the National Institute of Health database. The fact remains, no corporation should be able to come in to an already established town and make it dangerous to live in.” What more is there to say?

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
RECENT COMMENTARY
Monday, Mar 17, 2025
Old Town Newhall has earned its title as Santa Clarita’s Premier Arts and Entertainment District and has also become well-known as a hub for prime dining and shopping.
Friday, Mar 14, 2025
After the January wildfires, the county began a review to assess our evacuation policies and emergency alert systems. The state has also commissioned a review of our preparedness efforts, immediate response to the fires and the recovery time frame of the incident.
Thursday, Mar 13, 2025
As you drive through Santa Clarita, you may have noticed something exciting, new projects are taking shape all around the city.
Tuesday, Mar 11, 2025
Our community is rich with history, blending the spirit of the Old West with the history of our great nation, especially in our parks. When Santa Clarita incorporated in 1987, we only had eight parks. Today, we are home to more than three dozen, and this year, we are excited to welcome not just two new parks.
Thursday, Mar 6, 2025
In response to proposed cuts to the Department of Veterans Affairs by the federal administration, Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo issued a statement which is available for press interviews after the legislative session today or by phone and video.
Thursday, Mar 6, 2025
Throughout my entire life, I have surrounded myself with animals, whether it is my beloved donkey, cattle dogs or horses, animals truly do have incredible personalities and dynamic feelings.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1919 - Fire destroys abandoned second Southern Hotel, built 1878 in Newhall (corner Main & Market) [story]
Second Southern Hotel
The regular meeting of the William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board of Trustees will be held Wednesday, March 19, beginning with a closed session at 6:15 p.m., followed by an open session at 7 p.m.
March 19: Hart Board Considers Appointment of Fiscal Services Director
Join the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce for a Grand Opening Ribbon Cutting at Beyond Harmony Medical Spa & Luxury Aesthetics, Wednesday, March 26 at 4 p.m.
March 26: Beyond Harmony Grand Opening Ribbon Cutting
The city of Santa Clarita invites residents to purchase tickets for the 46th Annual city of Santa Clarita Dodger Day.
June 21: Santa Clarita Dodger Day Returns
The Small Business Development Center and city of Santa Clarita will host two Enhancing Your Digital Footprint series webinars, noon-1 p.m. Wednesdays, March 19 and 26.
March 19, 26: Enhancing Your Digital Footprint Series
Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo, D-Chatsworth, has introduced a legislation package which includes the Victim and Witness Protection Act (AB 535), Small Business Retail Theft Grants (AB 949), Police Pension Tax Exemption (AB 814) and protecting funding for crime victims (VOCA Funding Act) in the state budget.
Schiavo Advances Public, Victim, Small Business Safety Legislation
On Wednesday, April 2 6-8:30 p.m., Serata Italiana, the renowned Italian language and culture club, will host an exclusive event at Total Wine & More featuring real estate expert Natalie Blancardi and a virtual introduction to Italian attorney Antonello Pierro.
April 2: Total Wine & More Hosts Serata Italiana Event
The city of Santa Clarita Film Office has released the list of eight productions filming in the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Monday, March 17 to Saturday, March 22.
March 17-22: Eight Productions Filming in SCV
The track teams of The Master's University maintained their strong start to the 2025 outdoor season at the Ross and Sharon Irwin Classic on Saturday. March 15 in San Diego. Five standards were added and 11 top-10 marks in school history were achieved.
Mustangs’ Track Teams Crush Point Loma Meet
The Master's University men's basketball team's season ended Saturday night, March 15 as the Southern Oregon Raiders defeated the Mustangs 76-71 in The MacArthur Center.
Season Ends for TMU Men’s Hoops
Old Town Newhall has earned its title as Santa Clarita’s Premier Arts and Entertainment District and has also become well-known as a hub for prime dining and shopping.
Ken Striplin | Stimulating the SENSES in Old Town Newhall
The Master's University women's basketball team's season came to an end with its first round loss in the NAIA Women's Basketball National Championship Tournament on Saturday, March 15.
Season Ends in Oklahoma for Lady Mustangs
Braden Van Groningen collected 24 kills as The Master's University men's volleyball team came back to defeat the OUAZ Spirit 23-25, 25-17, 25-18, 25-13 Saturday afternoon, March 15 in The MacArthur Center.
Mustangs Get to 4-0 With Four-Set Win Over OUAZ
1927 - Newhall telephone exchange, est. 1900, now serves 100 phones [story]
telephone
2003 - Lifesize sculpture honoring heroes of St. Francis Dam disaster unveiled in Santa Paula [video]
The Warning
1942 - Emery Whilton's Florafaunium opens in Lebec [story]
Florafaunium
Today in SCV History (March 15)
After the January wildfires, the county began a review to assess our evacuation policies and emergency alert systems. The state has also commissioned a review of our preparedness efforts, immediate response to the fires and the recovery time frame of the incident.
Kathryn Barger | Wildfire Analysis
Island Pacific Santa Clarita is gearing up for a celebration of National Lumpia Day with a lumpia-eating contest on Saturday, March 15, from 3-6:30 p.m.
March 15: Lumpia Eating Contest at Island Pacific Santa Clarita
The regular meeting of the Saugus Union School District Governing Board of Trustees will be held Tuesday, March 18 beginning at 6:30 p.m.
March 18: Saugus School Board to Receive Measure EE Annual Report
After a successful pilot program in the Saugus Union School District, School Day Café has expanded the use of a new, eco-friendly serving tray option across all Santa Clarita Valley elementary schools.
SCV Elementary School Lunches Offered on Eco-friendly Serving Trays
In support of “Making Water Conservation a California Way of Life,” the Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency is developing a Water Use Efficiency Strategic Plan to establish a comprehensive water conservation strategy.
March 26: SCV Water Hosts Public Workshop on Water Use Efficiency Plan
College of the Canyons Women's Tennis got back in the win column with an 8-1 conference road win at Glendale College.
Canyons Gets Back in the Win Column 8-1 at Glendale
The Michael Hoefflin Foundation for Children’s Cancer invites the community to join the annual "Walk 4 MHF Help Kids Fight Cancer" to help raise awareness and support local families affected by childhood cancer.
April 5: Annual Walk 4 MHF Help Kids Fight Cancer at Central Park
The Santa Clarita Valley Historical Society has announced that the St. Francis Dam Tour scheduled for Saturday, March 15 has been postponed until Saturday, April 26.
March 15: St. Francis Dam Tour Postponed Due to Rain
SCVNews.com