5/25/2013 Obama's Weekly Address | Giving Thanks to Our Fallen Heroes on Memorial Day => http://t.co/hiSfuBEFPS
SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: One Small Victory for Anti-School Choice, One Giant Opportunity for Einstein Academy | 10-25-2012
Inside
Weather
Weather Forecast
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
May 25
1966 - Mustang Drive-In theater opens on Soledad Canyon Road [story]


One Small Victory for Anti-School Choice, One Giant Opportunity for Einstein Academy
Kevin D. Korenthal | Thursday, Oct 25, 2012
Get Our Free Daily Morning News Digest In Your E-Mail
Print Friendly Version of this pagePrint Get a PDF version of this webpagePDF
Tweet This! Tweet This
Share on Facebook Facebook
Digg it! Digg This
Add to Delicious! Bookmark
Stumble it Stumble
Subscribe by RSS RSS

Kevin D. Korenthal

After eight years of working in government affairs and association public relations, I thought I’d seen how low an adversary can sink in order to score a victory. I was, after all, advocating against the most powerful special interest group of all time, Big Labor. And in that respect, my work remains the same. But instead of the well-funded private unions of the building trades, my most recent opponent was the politically powerful and often-maligned, public employee union, the California Teachers Association.  It is noteworthy that Mitt Romney took the time in the last debate to point out that it is the teachers’ unions, not the students, parents, and teachers who are the real beneficiaries of our education system.

The California Teachers Association wields its power silently but effectively in our K-6 elementary school system here in the Santa Clarita Valley. They claim that Santa Clarita has great schools that are not in need of reform or competition and that we have them to thank for that. In reality, SCV schools have been slashing course offerings and drastically increasing class sizes for decades, all the while, they send each class off to college less prepared than the last. Certainly, our schools are not failing but they are based on the increasingly unpopular premise that an ever greater amount of money and a very powerful and well-paid administration is the key to successfully educating children. They argue that education reform, especially in the form of competition is unnecessary and counterintuitive. Were this all true, California would not be ranked 47th in schools in the nation despite having the 23rd highest per pupil spending in the country.

So we have an education system with a clear conflict of interest in the position of deciding whether or not the charter proposed by the Albert Einstein Academy for Letters, Arts & Sciences is approved or denied. By the reaction Einstein Academy has received from the education establishment, you’d have thought that they were proposing some never-before-heard-of plan to completely reform our schools. Actually, the California State Legislature chose charter schools over school vouchers in an attempt placate the unions that wanted nothing to do with any sort of reform or competition. And the reaction to Einstein’s charter petition continues to provide evidence that the resistance remains. From the very beginning of the process, the unionized administrators for the local school districts began colluding to keep charters (especially Einstein) out of the Santa Clarita Valley.

Newhall School District Superintendent Marc Winger has gone as far as to insinuate that charters would be ruinous to the local education system we have here in the SCV. He’s indicated by his actions, allegedly with the support of the school board trustees at whose pleasure he serves, that he will stop at nothing to prevent charters from becoming a part of the K-6 districts.

Despite this, I am still surprised at the lengths that the Saugus Union School District went to deny Einstein Academy’s well-polished and significantly detailed charter petition. Rather than making a reasoned and convincing case that charter schools are, for whatever reason, unneeded in the Santa Clarita Valley, the Saugus administration chose to use obfuscation and deception to paint a negative picture of the Einstein charter.

Having the background in these matters that I do, I possess the ability to assess the accuracy and suitability of claims made by staff in these types of documents. Never before have I come across so many untrue statements and omissions.  Issues I found ranged from numerous claims by the district that voluminous answers to basic questions were just one sentence in length, subjective determinations on enrollment expectations that completely ignored supporting data contained in the petition, and the use of outdated and irrelevant data in cases where updated information was made available through the proper channels.  Additionally, there was a claim by the district that it actually possesses the same authority as the California Office of Education, as well as a baffling instance of the district staff being unable to identify the difference between liability insurance and Workers Compensation coverage.

The Saugus Union School District and their handlers in the local chapter of the California Teachers Association won a brief but costly victory here. Having had a clean and technically proficient charter school petition turned down by the district, Einstein Academy now qualifies to take its case to the Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) for a review of the SUSD findings. Upon denial at SUSD, Einstein immediately began the process of applying to LACOE to have the denial overturned on the basis that its petition was not evaluated fairly and according to the letter and intent of the law. With that documented in the form of the SUSD staff report and numerous white papers analyzing the errors and omissions contained therein, it is very likely that the LACOE will see things from Einstein’s perspective and approve the charter.

And a charter approved by LACOE will have some very distinct advantages over one SUSD should have approved. The LACOE-approved Einstein would have access to the average daily attendance tax increment from the Saugus district but would not be subject to the district’s oversight. It would also not be bound by the geographical limitations of the district. Einstein would be able to set up its charter school anywhere in the county and expansion would be significantly easier under the county’s supervision. Most ruinous from the eventual perspective of the district is the loss of revenue that Einstein would have returned to the district. Einstein would have been dependent in part on services that it would be provided with (at a handsome cost) by the district. Instead, a LACOE-approved Einstein will contract with private entities or another more willing district for these services.

So in the very short term, the K-6th school districts in Santa Clarita held off the wave of school choice and educational reform that is sweeping across the nation in the form of charter schools. But by doing so, it placed itself in further economic jeopardy and made itself a target for larger, better funded and completely privately run charter school corporations like Green Dot and Kipp. These very experienced and well-funded charter school companies relish the idea of smashing the doors wide open to school choice at throwback districts big and small. They’ll come with the talent and organization as well as the money to litigate when they don’t get the results they are looking for.

 

Kevin D. Korenthal is a Santa Clarita resident and the owner of KORE Communications, a marketing firm that represented Einstein Academy before the Saugus Union School Board. His commentary reflects his own views and not necessarily those of Einstein Academy or any other party.

Share this story:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • More
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • StumbleUpon
  • MySpace
  • Delicious
Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.
  • Kelly

    Per Mr.Korenthal, “it is very likely that the LACOE will see things from Einstein’s perspective and approve the charter”
    And if they don’t, (because LACOE also might have a vested interest against charters, Einstein, etc.) then what?

    • http://www.facebook.com/kkorenthal Kevin D. Korenthal

      I believe LACOE has a vested interest in ensuring that the charter schools that come before them meet the legal obligations set before them for approval. Though SUSD had that same obligation, I believe, their policy of preventing charter schools from entering the K-6th districts biased them in this process.

  • Robin

    Well written, Mr Korenthal. During this ongoing debate two things in particular have been especially disturbing:
    1. The net effect of Winger’s blanket opposition to charter schools? No child in his district will ever have the opportunity to begin learning a foreign language at a reasonably early age.
    2. Signal commentator Tim Myers made an outrageous claim against
    Einstein Academy parents, that they “had their hands in the public
    till”. This inflammatory language met The Signal’s writers’ guidelines?
    Best of luck with the LACOE.

  • TBF

    As the parents of a special needs child, we know full well how low the District can get in their self-serving interest to protect the District’s interest (namely save money and preserve themselves) and avoid providing appropriate services to the special needs child (and the general education child).

    Denials, lies, deception, continual intimidation of the parents with the threat of Due Process (paid for by the Taxpayer’s money), defamation of the child and their family, nothing is too far for the District.

    I know too well what Einstein must have gone through in their pursuit for their charter. I wish you luck in your pursuit.

    Time for education reform has come in the Santa Clarita Valley and in California at large:

    1) The class size has gone up to a level that is unacceptable and inappropriate for free and appropriate education.

    2) Class curriculum such as the arts, PE, languages., etc. have been stripped away to a level that is unacceptable and inappropriate for free and appropriate education.

    3) Great teachers who are so deserving are let go, while undeserving teachers (who do the bare minimum, who bully their students, and/or who have personality issues) are kept on (because of tenure).

    4) Certain demongraphics such as the ESL students, the economically disadvantaged students, the students with disabilities are not being served appropriately (they continually fail to make Adequate Yearly Progress as mandated).

    5) The public schools should not have a monopoly of the public education funds when they are not doing its job appropriately. Competition (in the form of charters or vouchers to private schools) should be allowed to give the child a choice to appropriate education.

    The parents have to rise up and stand up and fight for the rights of their Civil Rights to a Free and Appropriate Education for their children. Even if it means standing up to the intimidation of the local District and lobbying for laws to a free choice in education.

Commentary Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: INFO (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...

Betty Arenson

Jennifer Fischer

Carl Kanowsky

Mayor Bob Kellar

Kevin D. Korenthal

Darryl Manzer

Rep. Buck McKeon

Joe Messina

Tammy Messina

Ken Striplin

Evelyne Vandersande

Charlie Vignola

Hon. Scott Wilk

John Zaring
Related Content
 
  • Acton-AD School Board Considers Einstein Charter
  • SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, May 1, 2013
  • SCV Amputee Selected to Bike 620 Miles, S.F. to San Diego (Video)
  • SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, April 24, 2013
  • Saugus Board Again Rejects Einstein's Charter Bid
RECENT COMMENTARY
> MORE COMMENTARY

ABCs of the SCV: P is for Pizza

ABCs of the SCV: P is for Pizza
Saturday, May 25, 2013
What family can live without pizza? Serious, right? I asked around to find out what people think is the best pizza in the SCV.
READ MORE...

The Busiest News Week in Years

The Busiest News Week in Years
Thursday, May 23, 2013
Apparently, the zombie-like media felt they had to hide the Obama-Clinton cover-ups like some moms cover their kids’ shortcomings.
READ MORE...

COEXIST is Not for Me

COEXIST is Not for Me
Tuesday, May 7, 2013
My biggest issue with many on the COEXIST side is that they are quick to let those of us who want to hold strong to our Christian beliefs just how wrong we are.
READ MORE...

American Capitalism Needs to be Repaired

American Capitalism Needs to be Repaired
Tuesday, May 7, 2013
According to Emmanuel Saez, a renowned economics professor at U.C. Berkeley, the top one percent of households captured 121 percent of all income gains between 2009 and 2011, during the first two years of the economic recovery.
READ MORE...

ABCs of the SCV: ‘O’ is for Out of Town

ABCs of the SCV: ‘O’ is for Out of Town
Saturday, May 4, 2013
I am sharing my favorite “Out of Town Adventures for the Family” this week.
READ MORE...

Terrorists Caught in U.S. Should be Tried in Federal Courts

Terrorists Caught in U.S. Should be Tried in Federal Courts
Friday, May 3, 2013
Holding American citizens who have been arrested on U.S. soil in indefinite military detention is absolutely incompatible with our values.
READ MORE...

-->
Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Hurricane Harbor Opens for 2013 Season
Six Flags Hurricane Harbor splashes into a much-anticipated arrival of summer by opening its gates for the 19th season Saturday.
Hurricane Harbor Opens for 2013 Season
ABCs of the SCV: P is for Pizza
What family can live without pizza? Serious, right? I asked around to find out what people think is the best pizza in the SCV.
ABCs of the SCV: P is for Pizza
Today in SCV History (May 25)
1966 - Mustang Drive-In theater opens on Soledad Canyon Road [story]
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, May 24, 2013
In this episode: Six Flags Hurricane Harbor splashes into a much-anticipated arrival of summer by opening its gates for the 19th season Saturday. And more.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, May 24, 2013
The Master’s Wins Game 1 of College World Series
GSAC Pitcher of the Year A.J. Work gets his 13th win of the season.
The Master’s Wins Game 1 of College World Series
NAIA Men’s Track National Championships Recap: Day 1
The Master’s College was represented by Matthew Crichton in the Men’s 1,500 prelim, David Eller in the men’s 3,000m steeplechase prelim, and John Gilbertson in the 10,000m final.
NAIA Men’s Track National Championships Recap: Day 1
Lady Mustangs Track Performs Well at NAIA National Championships
Four TMC athletes very competitive at NAIA Division 1 National Championships
Lady Mustangs Track Performs Well at NAIA National Championships
Today in SCV History (May 24)
1860 - Colonel Thomas F. Mitchell arrives in Soledad Canyon [story]
Peterson, Founding Head of EDC, Leaving for Las Vegas
Jonas Peterson, who's been president of the Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corp. for the last three years, tendered his resignation as president and CEO last Monday.
Peterson, Founding Head of EDC, Leaving for Las Vegas
May 30: Summer Blood Drive at Henry Mayo
Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital invites the community to give the gift of life by donating blood during its summer blood drive on Thursday, May 30.
May 30: Summer Blood Drive at Henry Mayo
Wumbloozo Brings Back-Porch Acoustic Blues to All New Episode of SCVTV’s House Blend
The half-hour music-and-interview program premieres Saturday, May 25, at 10 p.m. Pacific Time on SCVTV, seen on Time-Warner Channel 20 in the Santa Clarita Valley and AT&T U-Verse 99 in Los Angeles and Orange counties. "House Blend" also streams live at www.scvtv.com at the same time.
Wumbloozo Brings Back-Porch Acoustic Blues to All New Episode of SCVTV’s House Blend
The Busiest News Week in Years
Apparently, the zombie-like media felt they had to hide the Obama-Clinton cover-ups like some moms cover their kids’ shortcomings.
The Busiest News Week in Years
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, May 23, 2013
In this episode: Live Oak Elementary was briefly put on lock down Thursday as firefighters battled a 5-acre bushfire in Castaic; COC administrator Dr. Ryan Theule has accepted the position of Dean of the Canyon Country campus, effective immediately. Jonas Peterson who is president and CEO of the Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corporation, which works in concert with the College of the Canyons, is resigning, officials announced this week.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, May 23, 2013
Theule Takes Helm of COC Canyon Country Campus
College of the Canyons administrator Dr. Ryan Theule has accepted the position of Dean of the Canyon Country campus, effective immediately.
Theule Takes Helm of COC Canyon Country Campus
Teens Pledge to Drive Safe During Graduation Season
"Graduation is a time of celebration and we want each and every senior to make it home safe this year,” said Mayor Bob Kellar. “I encourage graduating seniors and community members to wear a white ribbon during graduation as a way of honoring those we have lost and as a pledge to drive safe and act responsibly this graduation season.”
Teens Pledge to Drive Safe During Graduation Season
May 29-30: COC Theatre Presents ‘Solopalooza 2013′
Starbucks regulars, online dating, addiction, Cupid and the advantages of depression are just a few of the subjects that will be brought to life at Solopalooza 2013.
May 29-30: COC Theatre Presents ‘Solopalooza 2013′
Blotter: Rape, Thefts Reported in Newhall
Newhall, Zone 6 Public Safety and Crime Prevention Information Snapshot for 05/13/13 through 05/19/13
Blotter: Rape, Thefts Reported in Newhall
Ventura County CHP Stepping It Up for Memorial Day
Starting on Memorial Day weekend, the Ventura Area CHP office will have extra officers patrolling several areas in western Ventura County in response to the high number of speed related injury traffic collisions involving motorcycles.
Ventura County CHP Stepping It Up for Memorial Day
Today in SCV History (May 23)
1941 - SCV's first real movie house, the American Theater, dedicated in Newhall [story]
Sulphur Springs Takes Home the Trophy in an Annual Go Tournament (Video)
These students have been learning the ancient board game of Go from Joe Walters, the American Go Foundation's 2012 Teacher of the Year.
Sulphur Springs Takes Home the Trophy in an Annual Go Tournament (Video)
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, May 22, 2013
In this episode: A Saugus man who has been the sole subject of a murder investigation for nearly two years was ordered to stand trial Tuesday for the death of his girlfriend; A Canyon Country teen is being held on $1 million bail in connection to a stabbing that took place Tuesday night.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, May 22, 2013
Saugus Murder Suspect to Stand Trial
Los Angles Superior court judge Lloyd Nash found there was sufficient evidence to order Eric Earle, 41, of Saugus, to stand trial in the death of his live-in girlfriend.
Saugus Murder Suspect to Stand Trial
Canyon Country Stabbing Suspect Arrested
Steven Markarian, 19, of Canyon Country, a suspected gang member, is being booked for attempted murder, and he's being held at the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station in lieu of $1 million bail.
Canyon Country Stabbing Suspect Arrested
Detectives Seek Victims in “Stephen Disney” Scam
On Tuesday, May 21st, 2013, Stephen Urquidez was arrested on felony burglary charges for allegedly stealing the Disneyland passes. He was also in possession of a driver’s license containing a forged state seal, a felony. He was booked at Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station. Hours later he posted a $20,000 bond and was released.
Detectives Seek Victims in “Stephen Disney” Scam
| HOME | NEWS | SPORTS | BUSINESS | ENTERTAINMENT | GAME OF THE WEEK | Contact | Watch SCVTV |
SCVNews.com is another service of SCVTV: Local Television for Santa Clarita. Site contents ©SCVTV.