[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Santa Clarita CA
Mostly sunny
Mostly sunny
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 19
1863 - Gen. Edward F. Beale loans money to A.A. Hudson and Oliver P. Robbins to erect toll house in Newhall Pass [story]

Now and Then in the SCV | Commentary by Darryl Manzer
| Saturday, Sep 20, 2014
(CLICK TO ENLARGE) Top: Postings made on SCVNews.com by "Steve Roter," alias Vanessa Brookman (above), who chairs the Val Verde Community Advisory Committee, a county-appointed panel which serves as the official liaison between the landfill operator and the community. For violating the published SCVNews.com terms of service (see above right) - perpetrating a fraud by repeatedly using a fake name to make "libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements," only a sampling of which appear here - the user has been banned.

darrylmanzer_blacktieOK. I admit it. I was wrong. What I wrote yesterday was not entirely accurate. What the heck, when it comes to writing about the expansion of Chiquita Canyon Landfill, it isn’t easy to be accurate. So much has been said and printed and rumored.

In all the many times I’ve written about the dump in the last couple of months, I kept thinking all the folks involved had at least a little bit of honor and ethics left. I’ve found out I was wrong on that, too.

Each year the folks from Chiquita Canyon Landfill give many thousands of dollars to various groups in and outside of Val Verde. It appears they have spread a lot of money around to mask some of the things they are really doing.

You name the charity or other organization in need, and there is the dump. There are some political campaigns and services for political concerns that they have helped. We may never know how much they are spending on the charities they help. It looks like a hefty price. The money they give to Val Verde this year is $340,000, and it could nearly double if the expansion is approved.

The Castaic Area Town Council has negotiated a contract to have a benefits fund created just like the one in Val Verde (see below). This is the subject about which I was wrong. You see, I thought the only folks who couldn’t disagree with the landfill expansion were the members of the Castaic Area Town Council and their families. What I as wrong about is that the contract they approved says, and I quote from Item 20 of the contract:

“20. In the event that the CATC, any officer, director, employee or agent of CATC, including any family members or co-habitants or any person or entity whose residence or business is located in the Castaic Area initiates any appeal of any project approval or joins in or supports in any way any appeal of Project approvals, including without limitation an appeal to the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors or filing any administrative or judicial challenge to the Project or the EIR or any Project approvals including those required by the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”), this Agreement shall be voidable and of no further force and effect in CCL’s sole discretion.”

So I was wrong. You see, it says ANYONE who lives or operates a business in the Castaic Area cannot do anything to stop the expansion of the landfill. The Castaic Area Town Council not only gave up the First Amendment for themselves; they did so for the whole area, as well. I’ll try not to be so inaccurate next time – well, this time.

Here is another item in the “Memorandum of Agreement,” or contract, which states in Item 11.d:

“None of the 9 seats can be filled by a Val Verde resident or an owner of property in Val Verde.”

Item 11 is how the CCCCCBF, or Chiquita Canyon Castaic Community Benefits Fund, shall be created. (All dictated by the dump.)

So nobody within the area that is covered by the Castaic Area Town Council can say anything ill about the landfill or its expansion, and Val Verde cannot be on the Castaic Benefits committee. All this for something entirely in the confines of Val Verde’s traditional boundaries.

Let me state that even more plainly: It isn’t a problem for Castaic, yet they want some money. What a crock of bovine scatology this is, my friends.

So all y’all who live in the Castaic Area can’t say anything good or bad about the dump unless you want to be blamed for preventing a lot of money going to the Castaic Benefits committee.

We’re also told the new agreement proposed for Val Verde will read about the same way. I wonder who is going to approve it?

I want to thank Steve Roter, aka Vanessa Brookman, for dashing any hopes I had that most folks in this discussion had some remaining honor. I could never figure out what Steve Roter was writing about. Brookman – the Antonovich appointee who chairs the existing Val Verde benefits committee – publicly admitted Friday that she is “Steve Roter,” and now we all know. Her duplicity in the comments she posted on my articles is exceeded only by the way she degraded the residents of Val Verde in and out of meetings. I feel sad that someone would stoop so low. I hope she can get some help.

This tale just gets more and more twisted. There are books that don’t have as many twists in plot and characters. It isn’t over yet.

Stay tuned for another chapter of “As the Dump Smells.” Coming soon. Don’t miss it.



Darryl Manzer grew up in the Pico Canyon oil town of Mentryville in the 1960s and attended Hart High School. After a career in the U.S. Navy he returned to live in the Santa Clarita Valley. He can be reached at dmanzer@scvhistory.com. His older commentaries are archived at DManzer.com; his newer commentaries can be accessed [here]. Watch his walking tour of Mentryville [here].


CCCCBF Contract 1CCCCBF Contract 2CCCCBF Contract 3CCCCBF Contract 4CCCCBF Contract 5CCCCBF Contract 6CCCCBF Contract 7CCCCBF Contract 8

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


  1. msc545 says:

    I am expecting a lawsuit will be filed over this by someone ? Hopefully ?

  2. Steve Lee says:

    Wow, I am the resident from Val Verde that she called a fear monger, tool, and idiot. I am just one of the ones that she cares so much about. I agree that help is needed. Too sit on a board that is suppose to listen to its residents and to call them names the entire time is disturbing. There are free groups out there somewhere that could help her. That would be a start.

  3. Kathy Howse says:

    Should it even be possible for a few to vote agreeing to something that will affect many? Something this impacting should be voted on by the whole community. Are the people in Castaic even fully aware of what has happened and what it means?
    The concern should be why is there even a need to restrict anyone’s comments concerning the landfill? Could it be the landfill knows there will be complaints and concerns? something Castaic hasn’t experienced yet.
    Listen to the comments from Val Verde and think about it.

  4. Thank you Darryl Manzer, a one-man csi, for digging into this messy issue. I think your findings are probably very accurate and that we scv dwellers will regret this dump expansion forever more.

  5. Thank you Darryl Manzer, a one-man csi, for digging into this messy issue. I think your findings are probably very accurate and that we scv dwellers will regret this dump expansion forever more.

  6. C4CCLC says:

    If you want to see footage of the video please visit: http://chiquitalandfill.net/audio-partial-video-catc-917-meeting/

    There is also a link there to a pdf of the agreement.

  7. The problem is, too much garbage from too many people going to too few dumps that are filling up too fast. Most cities are suffering the same plight!politics and Darryl’s rant, are just a cover up for the “we don’t want your garbage in our back yard”mentality. Use less plastic,recycle more, make a compost pile,use cloth diapers too, then you’ll make a difference. Otherwise grow the dumps!

Leave a Comment

Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Friday, Sep 14, 2018
Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage have different benefits and costs that you should consider based on your personal needs. Medicare open enrollment season runs from Oct. 15 to Dec. 7, and it’s a good idea to know how the two types of Medicare work before you select one.
Wednesday, Sep 5, 2018
In his September column, Santa Clarita City Manager Ken Striplin outlines the city's 'Heads up' safety campaign against distracted driving and walking.
Tuesday, Sep 4, 2018
Nestled between the sports fields and hiking trails at Central Park is a grove of tree stumps.
Wednesday, Aug 22, 2018
If we can secure U.S. Rep. Steve Knight’s leadership, we have the chance to improve recreational opportunities and protect open space in the mountains that flank and define the Santa Clarita Valley.
Thursday, Aug 2, 2018
City Manager Ken Striplin notes that a lot has changed in Santa Clarita since the 1970s, except the SCV Sheriff's Station, which opened 46 years ago and will finally be replaced by a brand-new 46,000-square-foot, state-of-the-art, centrally located Sheriff’s Station on Golden Valley Road.
Wednesday, Aug 1, 2018
​There are many things that make our City the unique and special place it is.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1863 - Gen. Edward F. Beale loans money to A.A. Hudson and Oliver P. Robbins to erect toll house in Newhall Pass [story]
Gibbon-Fest will take place Saturday, Oct. 13, from 11:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m., at the Gibbon Conservation Center, located at 19100 Esguerra Rd., Santa Clarita, 91390.
Oct. 13: Gibbon-Fest at Gibbon Conservation Center
The date has changed, but the SCV Senior Center's Touch-A-Truck event is still a landmark event for children and adults who are intrigued with vehicles of all sorts and uses.
Oct. 13: Touch-A-Truck Benefiting SCV Senior Center
The next Canyon Country Advisory Committee (CCAC) meeting will be held Wednesday, Sept. 19, from 7:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m.
Sept. 19: Canyon Country Advisory Committee Meeting
BAKERSFIELD — College of the Canyons freshman Haruka Koda fired a round of 70 to earn medalist honors and lead the Lady Cougars to a third straight Western State Conference (WSC) tourney victory on Monday at Kern River Golf Club.
Lady Cougars Bring Home 3rd Straight Western State Conference Tourney Win
The William S. Hart Union High School District's Parent and Student Empowerment (PASE) program presents, "Every Life Matters," Preventing Suicide in Teens & Children.
Sept. 20: Hart District’s PASE Presents ‘Every Life Matters’; Preventing Teen Suicides
The Michael Hoefflin Foundation is looking for volunteers for its upcoming 25th Annual Evening Under the Stars Gala Dinner and Charity Auction.
Michael Hoefflin Foundation In Need of Volunteers for Annual Gala
NORTHRIDGE - Over 60 Matadors spanning three teams took part in the 2018 Coastal Cleanup Day on Saturday. The CSUN Women's Soccer, Women's Water Polo and Women's Tennis teams all participated in the worldwide event in effort to give back and beautify their community.
Dozens of Matadors Take Part in 2018 Coastal Cleanup Day
IRVINE - For the second time in three weeks, CSUN's Daniel Trejo and Henrik Regitnig have swept the weekly Big West Conference men's soccer honors as the Matadors climbed to 13th in the Top Drawer Soccer Top 25 poll.
Pair of Matadors Sweep Big West Conference Awards
The Sheila R. Veloz Breast Center, a service of Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital, announces a very special “fun and fit” event at the Santa Clarita Athletic Club on Friday, Oct. 12.
Oct. 12: Ride for a Cure – Fight Breast Cancer with Janet Cheveres
Jonslist.org, a registered 501 (c)(3) nonprofit dedicated to protecting animals and the environment, is having the First Annual Five Knolls Halloween Dog Costume Contest Saturday, Oct. 27, from 9:00 a.m - 11:00 a.m.
Oct. 27: Five Knolls Halloween Dog Costume Contest
Enhanced Landscape Management, the maintenance division of Landscape Development Inc. (LDI) with headquarters located in Valencia, Calif., has concluded the asset purchase of Chateau Landscape Inc. (CLI) in Santa Clarita, Calif.
Landscape Development Inc. Concludes Purchase of Chateau Landscape Inc.
California State University, Northridge’s psychology professor Luciana Lagana received the Best Political Statement award at the Hollywood Dreamz International Film Festival, as well as the Phoenix Body of Work award at the 2018 Action on Film International Film Festival, for writing, directing and producing the documentary “Off the Streets for Good.”
CSUN Professor’s Documentary on Homelessness Garners Awards
The city of Santa Clarita has updated the list of productions shooting in the city and the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Sept. 10 – Sept. 16, 2018.
‘Lethal Weapon,’ ‘NCIS,’ ‘Trading Spaces’ Now Filming in SCV
The happy men of the SCV Men of Harmony Chorus are now preparing for their 42nd Annual A-capella Show and Ice Cream Social.
Oct. 13: SCV Men of Harmony Chorus A-capella Show, Ice Cream Social
Sierra Vista Junior High School parents were notified Monday about an incident of a male suspect attempting to lure a student.
School Issues Warning After Suspect Tries to Lure Student
1962 - Articles of incorporation filed for Golden State Memorial Hospital on Lyons Avenue [story]
Dodger outfielder Yasiel Puig has been named the National League Player of the Week presented by W.B. Mason for the period ending Sept. 16, the team announced Monday.
Dodgers’ Yasiel Puig Named National League Player of the Week
Writer, photographer and former CalArts Critical Studies faculty Janet Sternburg will present her first solo U.S. museum show, titled 'LIMBUS,' at USC’s Fisher Museum of Art from Sept. 18 to Dec. 1.
Sept. 18: Janet Sternburg to Open ‘LIMBUS’ at USC’s Fisher Museum
CalArts acting student Pricilla Chung's Instagram account caught the eye of New York Magazine’s fashion blog The Cut, and editors invited her to NYC for a photo shoot and feature write-up.
CalArts Acting Student Pricilla Jin Chung Makes ‘The Cut’
For a team with goals that can't be reached until November, it's all about the progression from one meet to another right now for The Master's University men's cross country team.
TMU Men’s Cross Country Keeps Building Toward Goals
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has unveiled its fall programming lineup for both Los Angeles and New York.
‘Exorcist’ 45th Anniversary, ‘Christmas Story’ Top Fall Academy Screenings
Los Angeles County Supervisor Kathryn Barger and her Trail Blazers will host her second annual trail ride at Frank G. Bonelli Regional Park in San Dimas on Sunday, Oct. 21.
Oct. 21: Barger’s Trail Blazers to Ride at Bonelli Regional Park
Mikala Fairchild led all Mustangs women's cross country runners at Saturday's UC Riverside Invitational, finishing 21st overall in the 5,000-meter open race.
Fairchild, Ghiorso Lead the Way for TMU Women’s Cross Country
The TMU Mustangs men's soccer team beat No. 14 Marymount California University 3-1 at El Camino College in Torrance on Saturday.
Mangan Leads Mustangs Past No. 14 Marymount Cal
Senior Hailey Gomillion scored in the 105th minute to lift No. 24 TMU to a 1-0 win over Marymount California University.
Gomillion’s Goal Lifts TMU to Win in 105th Minute
The Master's University women's volleyball team completed a sweep of No. 7 Westmont College on Saturday, ending the Warriors' 32-match winning streak in conference play.
Master’s Snaps Westmont’s 32-Match GSAC Win Streak
The Salvation Army Santa Clarita Valley Corps proudly marched in this year’s Agua Dulce Country Fair Parade on Saturday, with Envoys Jerry and Laura Bloom and the Salvation Army Kettle Bug leading a group of lively volunteers down the parade route.
Salvation Army Joins March in Agua Dulce Parade
The William S. Hart Union High School District needs a new member of the Measure SA Citizens’ Oversight Committee.
Hart District Seeks Member for Measure SA Oversight Panel
Matthew L. Fielding, 25, of La Crescenta, was killed when his motorcycle collided with a car on Interstate 5 in the Newhall Pass on Sunday morning, according to the CHP.
La Crescenta Motorcyclist Dies in I-5 Collision
Michael Foley began serving as the Executive Director of Bridge to Home on Monday, Sept. 17.
Michael Foley is New Bridge to Home Exec Director
A woman who was barricaded in a Castaic apartment after allegedly firing a gun during a welfare check in Castaic Friday afternoon surrendered to authorities after several hours of negotiation.
Barricaded Woman Surrenders in Castaic
A coalition of 56 state attorneys general including California's sent a letter to the U.S. Congress Monday calling on lawmakers to reauthorize the Violence Against Women Act.
State AG’s Urge Feds to Renew Violence Against Women Act
California Governor Edmund G. Brown Jr. joined Baden-Württemberg Minister-President Winfried Kretschmann Saturday to sign an agreement establishing a sister state relationship between California and Baden-Württemberg, Germany.
Brown Signs Sister State Agreement with Baden-Württemberg, Germany
1879 - First official Newhall School building erected near Walnut & Ninth streets [story]